critical thinking supervisor interview questions

Better resumes & cover letters

AI Resume Builder

Resume Checker

AI Cover Letters

Resume Summary Generator

Resume Bullet Generator

Resume Skills Generator

Tailor your resume to jobs

Job Tailored Resumes

Resume Keyword Scanner

Job Keyword Finder

Organize your search

Job Tracker

Contact Tracker

Interview Tracker

Job Search Metrics

Speed up your search

Job Application Autofill

Chrome Extension

• For Organizations
• University Career Centers
• Career Coaches
• Workforce Development
• Outplacement
• Affiliate Program

Targeted Resume

Beautiful, perfectly job-tailored resumes designed to make you stand out, built 10x faster with the power of AI.

• For Organizations University Career Centers Career Coaches Bootcamps Workforce Development Outplacement Affiliate Program
• Sign up for free

Interview Questions

50 Interview Questions About Critical Thinking (With Answers)

Being able to look at something deeply can change your perspective. Here are 50 interview questions about critical thinking.

May 18, 2024

The ability to think critically can help companies save money and solve problems better. This post includes 50 interview questions about critical thinking and why you need to think critically at work.

Get more interview questions.

Sign up for Huntr to access interview questions tailored to the job you're applying for.

What is critical thinking?

Critical thinking is a vital soft skill that involves the objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgment. It encompasses the ability to logically and coherently reason, reflect, and connect ideas, discern between facts and opinions, solve problems creatively, and make decisions based on evidence and sound reasoning rather than assumptions or emotional responses. Critical thinkers are characterized by their willingness to question assumptions, explore alternative viewpoints, and consider the implications of their decisions. This skill is crucial across various aspects of life, from personal decision-making to professional environments where strategic planning and effective problem-solving are key to success.

Why is critical thinking important in the workplace?

1. problem-solving efficiency.

Critical thinking equips employees with the ability to analyze complex problems, identify their root causes, and devise effective solutions. This skill is invaluable in navigating the challenges that arise in a dynamic work environment, ensuring that issues are resolved efficiently and innovatively.

2. Decision-Making Quality

In the fast-paced business world, making informed decisions is crucial. Critical thinking enables individuals to evaluate options critically, consider potential outcomes, and make decisions based on logic and evidence rather than impulse. This leads to better decision-making that can significantly impact the success and growth of an organization.

3. Enhanced Communication

Critical thinking also plays a key role in improving communication within the workplace. It encourages individuals to question assumptions, analyze information, and articulate their ideas clearly and logically. This fosters an environment of open dialogue and collaboration, where ideas are scrutinized constructively, leading to more robust strategies and solutions.

5 Tips for Answering Critical Thinking Interview Questions

When you're in an interview and faced with questions designed to assess your critical thinking skills, your responses can significantly impact the impression you leave on the hiring panel. Critical thinking is a valued skill across all professions, indicating your ability to analyze situations, make reasoned judgments, and solve problems effectively. Here are five tips to help you showcase your critical thinking abilities during an interview:

1. Understand the Question

Before diving into your answer, take a moment to fully understand the question. Critical thinking begins with comprehension. If necessary, ask for clarification. This shows you're attentive and committed to providing a thoughtful response.

2. Structure Your Response

Employ the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) to structure your answer. This technique helps you present your response in a coherent and logical sequence, illustrating your critical thinking process. Begin by describing a specific situation, outline the task you were faced with, detail the actions you took by applying your critical thinking skills, and conclude with the results of those actions.

3. Provide Examples

Use real-life examples from your previous experiences to demonstrate your critical thinking ability. Describing how you've applied critical thinking in past situations provides tangible evidence of your skill. Whether it was a problem you solved, a complex project you managed, or an innovative solution you developed, specific examples will make your answer more compelling.

4. Explain Your Thought Process

Don't just state what you did; delve into how and why you did it. Explain the reasoning behind your decisions and the factors you considered. This gives interviewers insight into your critical thinking process, showing them how you approach problems and evaluate solutions.

5. Reflect on What You Learned

Critical thinkers are also reflective thinkers. Conclude your response by sharing what you learned from the experience and how it enhanced your critical thinking skills. This demonstrates your ability to learn from situations and apply those lessons to future challenges, a key aspect of continuous improvement in critical thinking.

50 Interview Questions About Critical Thinking

1. how do you define critical thinking, and why is it important in the workplace.

Critical thinking is the process of analyzing and evaluating information objectively to make reasoned judgments. It involves questioning assumptions, assessing evidence, and considering different perspectives. In the workplace, critical thinking is essential for problem-solving, decision-making, and innovation. It helps employees navigate complex situations, improve processes, and make informed, strategic choices.

2. Can you give an example of a time when you used critical thinking to solve a complex problem?

In a previous role, our team faced a significant drop in customer satisfaction scores. Using critical thinking, I conducted a root cause analysis by gathering data from customer feedback, analyzing service processes, and interviewing team members. I identified that a recent change in our service protocol was causing delays. We revised the protocol, implemented additional training, and monitored the impact, resulting in improved customer satisfaction.

3. What steps do you take when analyzing information to ensure objectivity and accuracy?

To ensure objectivity and accuracy, I gather information from multiple reliable sources, cross-verify data, and avoid personal biases. I use critical questioning techniques to challenge assumptions and seek diverse perspectives to gain a comprehensive understanding. Additionally, I document and review my analysis process to identify any potential errors or gaps.

4. Can you share a situation where your critical thinking skills led to a significant improvement or innovation?

While working on a project to reduce production costs, I used critical thinking to analyze the entire production process. By identifying inefficiencies and redundancies, I proposed an automation solution that streamlined workflows and reduced manual labor. This innovation not only cut costs by 20% but also increased production speed and consistency.

5. How do you approach decision-making using critical thinking principles?

I approach decision-making by clearly defining the problem, gathering relevant data, and identifying possible solutions. I evaluate the pros and cons of each option, considering short-term and long-term impacts. I also seek input from stakeholders to ensure diverse perspectives. Finally, I make a well-reasoned decision and monitor the outcomes to learn and adjust as needed.

6. Can you describe a time when you had to challenge assumptions or conventional wisdom in a project or task?

In a marketing campaign, the conventional wisdom was to target the largest demographic. However, after analyzing customer data, I found that a smaller, niche demographic had higher engagement and conversion rates. I challenged the assumption and proposed a targeted campaign for this niche group. The result was a significant increase in ROI compared to previous campaigns.

7. What strategies do you use to gather and evaluate relevant data when making decisions?

I start by identifying the key questions and information needed for the decision. I gather data from credible sources such as industry reports, internal records, and expert opinions. I use analytical tools to evaluate the data, looking for patterns, trends, and correlations. Cross-referencing and triangulating data from different sources ensure a well-rounded analysis.

8. Can you give an example of a time when you had to make a decision based on incomplete or ambiguous information?

During a product launch, we faced ambiguous market data due to rapidly changing consumer trends. I gathered the best available data, consulted with market experts, and conducted a risk assessment. By making informed assumptions and preparing contingency plans, we proceeded with the launch, which turned out to be successful despite the initial uncertainties.

9. How do you handle situations where there are conflicting opinions or perspectives that require critical analysis?

I handle conflicting opinions by facilitating open discussions, actively listening to all viewpoints, and asking probing questions to understand the underlying reasons. I gather evidence supporting each perspective and objectively analyze the pros and cons. By synthesizing the information, I can make a balanced decision that considers diverse insights.

10. Can you share a situation where you had to adapt your approach or strategy based on new information or insights?

In a project to expand into a new market, initial research suggested a high demand for our product. However, new information from local market surveys indicated strong competition and different consumer preferences. I adapted our strategy by customizing our product features and marketing approach to align with local needs, resulting in a successful market entry.

11. What role does creativity play in your application of critical thinking skills?

Creativity enhances critical thinking by enabling the exploration of unconventional solutions and innovative approaches. It allows for thinking outside the box and generating new ideas that can solve problems more effectively. Creativity combined with critical thinking leads to well-rounded, imaginative, and practical solutions.

12. Can you describe a time when you had to prioritize multiple factors or criteria in a decision-making process?

In a project to select a new software vendor, I had to consider factors such as cost, functionality, user-friendliness, and customer support. I created a weighted scoring system to evaluate each vendor against these criteria. By prioritizing the most critical factors and using a systematic approach, we selected a vendor that best met our needs and budget.

13. How do you ensure that your conclusions and recommendations are logical and well-supported?

I ensure my conclusions and recommendations are logical and well-supported by basing them on thorough analysis and credible evidence. I use logical reasoning to connect data points and draw clear, well-supported conclusions. I also seek feedback from colleagues to validate my findings and recommendations.

14. Can you give an example of a time when you identified a potential risk or opportunity through critical analysis?

While analyzing sales data, I noticed a downward trend in a specific product category. Through further analysis, I identified changing consumer preferences as the root cause. This critical analysis allowed us to pivot our strategy, discontinuing low-performing products and investing in new product development, which capitalized on emerging consumer trends.

15. What steps do you take to evaluate the potential impact of your decisions on stakeholders and outcomes?

I identify all relevant stakeholders and consider how each decision will affect them. I gather input from stakeholders to understand their perspectives and concerns. I conduct impact assessments, weighing the pros and cons, and consider short-term and long-term implications. This comprehensive evaluation ensures decisions are balanced and considerate of all stakeholders.

16. Can you share a situation where your critical thinking skills helped you overcome a major obstacle or setback?

During a product development project, we faced a major technical setback that threatened our timeline. Using critical thinking, I organized a brainstorming session with the team, analyzed the root cause of the issue, and explored alternative solutions. We identified a viable workaround that allowed us to stay on track without compromising quality.

17. How do you handle situations where there is pressure to make quick decisions without sufficient information?

In high-pressure situations, I prioritize gathering the most critical information quickly. I consult with knowledgeable colleagues, use my experience to make informed assumptions, and prepare contingency plans. While I aim for the best possible decision, I remain flexible and ready to adjust as new information becomes available.

18. Can you describe a time when you had to consider ethical implications in your critical thinking process?

In a project to implement customer data analytics, I had to consider the ethical implications of data privacy. I conducted a thorough review of data protection regulations and consulted with legal experts. We implemented strict data anonymization and access controls, ensuring that our practices were ethical and compliant with privacy laws.

19. What role does collaboration play in enhancing your critical thinking abilities?

Collaboration brings diverse perspectives, knowledge, and expertise, which enrich critical thinking. Engaging with colleagues in discussions and brainstorming sessions helps identify blind spots, challenge assumptions, and develop well-rounded solutions. Collaboration fosters a collective approach to problem-solving, enhancing the quality of decisions.

20. Can you give an example of a time when you had to think outside the box to find a creative solution to a problem?

We faced declining engagement in our marketing campaigns. Thinking outside the box, I proposed leveraging user-generated content to create more authentic and relatable marketing materials. We launched a social media campaign encouraging customers to share their experiences, which significantly boosted engagement and brand loyalty.

21. How do you assess the reliability and credibility of sources when conducting research or gathering information?

I assess the reliability and credibility of sources by considering the author's expertise, the publication's reputation, and the evidence supporting the information. I cross-check information with multiple reputable sources and look for peer-reviewed articles, official reports, and data from established institutions to ensure accuracy.

22. Can you share a situation where you had to challenge a flawed or biased argument using critical thinking principles?

In a budget meeting, a colleague argued for cutting training programs based on short-term cost savings. I challenged this by presenting data on the long-term benefits of employee training, such as increased productivity and reduced turnover. By highlighting the flawed reasoning and providing evidence-based counterarguments, we retained the training budget.

23. What steps do you take to remain objective and open-minded when evaluating different perspectives?

I remain objective by actively listening to all perspectives, questioning my own assumptions, and seeking diverse viewpoints. I use evidence-based analysis and avoid letting personal biases influence my judgment. Keeping an open mind allows me to consider new ideas and solutions that I might not have initially recognized.

24. Can you describe a time when you had to analyze complex data sets or information to draw meaningful conclusions?

While working on a market research project, I analyzed complex data sets from multiple sources to identify consumer trends. I used statistical tools to identify patterns and correlations, cross-referenced findings with industry reports, and drew meaningful conclusions that informed our marketing strategy and product development roadmap.

25. How do you handle situations where there are conflicting priorities or goals that require critical prioritization?

I handle conflicting priorities by assessing the urgency and impact of each goal. I use a prioritization matrix to evaluate tasks based on factors such as importance, deadlines, and resource availability. By aligning priorities with organizational objectives and stakeholder needs, I ensure that critical tasks are addressed effectively and efficiently.

26. Can you give an example of a time when you had to analyze a process or workflow to identify inefficiencies or areas for improvement?

In a logistics project, I analyzed the order fulfillment process to identify inefficiencies. By mapping out each step and gathering input from the team, I identified bottlenecks and redundant tasks. We implemented process improvements, such as automation and better inventory management, which reduced lead times and increased efficiency.

27. What strategies do you use to communicate your critical thinking process and conclusions effectively to others?

I use clear and concise language, supported by data and evidence, to communicate my critical thinking process and conclusions. Visual aids, such as charts and diagrams, help illustrate key points. I ensure my arguments are logical and well-structured, and I encourage feedback and questions to clarify any uncertainties.

28. Can you share a situation where your critical thinking skills helped you anticipate and mitigate potential risks or challenges?

In a project to launch a new service, I anticipated potential risks related to customer adoption and technical challenges. I conducted a thorough risk assessment, developed mitigation strategies, and created contingency plans. This proactive approach helped us address issues promptly and ensured a smooth and successful launch.

29. How do you approach problem-solving using a structured and systematic critical thinking framework?

I approach problem-solving by defining the problem clearly, gathering relevant data, and identifying possible solutions. I evaluate each solution based on criteria such as feasibility, impact, and resources required. I select the best solution, implement it, and monitor the results to ensure it effectively addresses the problem.

30. Can you describe a time when you had to make a decision with limited resources or constraints that required creative critical thinking?

During a budget cut, we needed to maintain customer support quality with fewer resources. I proposed leveraging AI chatbots to handle common queries, freeing up human agents for complex issues. This creative solution maintained service quality, reduced costs, and improved efficiency despite the constraints.

31. What role does feedback play in refining and improving your critical thinking skills?

Feedback is essential for refining critical thinking skills as it provides insights into areas for improvement and alternative perspectives. Constructive feedback from colleagues and mentors helps identify blind spots, validate reasoning, and enhance decision-making processes. Continuous learning and adaptation based on feedback strengthen critical thinking abilities.

32. Can you give an example of a time when you had to evaluate the validity of an argument or claim using evidence and reasoning?

In a proposal to switch suppliers, the argument was made based on cost savings. I evaluated the claim by analyzing the long-term reliability, quality, and service levels of the new supplier. Evidence from industry reports and case studies revealed potential risks. Based on this analysis, we decided to maintain our current supplier to ensure quality and reliability.

33. How do you handle situations where there is uncertainty or ambiguity that requires critical analysis and judgment?

In uncertain situations, I gather as much relevant information as possible and identify key uncertainties. I use scenario analysis to evaluate potential outcomes and develop contingency plans. By consulting with experts and considering various perspectives, I make informed judgments that balance risks and benefits.

34. Can you share a situation where your critical thinking skills helped you identify patterns or trends that others may have overlooked?

In a sales performance review, I noticed a subtle but consistent decline in a particular product category. Further analysis revealed a shift in consumer preferences that others had overlooked. By identifying this trend early, we adjusted our product strategy and marketing efforts, ultimately improving sales and customer satisfaction.

35. What steps do you take to ensure that your solutions or recommendations are practical and feasible?

I ensure solutions are practical and feasible by considering resource availability, implementation timelines, and potential obstacles. I conduct pilot tests or simulations to validate the approach and gather feedback from stakeholders. Regularly reviewing and adjusting the plan based on real-world insights ensures successful implementation.

36. Can you describe a time when you had to analyze competing solutions or options to make an informed decision?

In a project to choose a new CRM system, we had multiple options with varying features and costs. I analyzed each option based on criteria such as user-friendliness, integration capabilities, and long-term ROI. By scoring and comparing the options, we selected the CRM system that best met our needs and budget.

37. How do you incorporate feedback and lessons learned from past experiences into your critical thinking approach?

I incorporate feedback and lessons learned by reflecting on past decisions and their outcomes. I document key insights and use them to inform future decision-making processes. Regularly reviewing successes and failures helps identify patterns, refine strategies, and improve critical thinking skills over time.

38. Can you give an example of a time when you had to challenge the status quo or traditional ways of thinking to drive positive change?

In a project to improve customer service, the traditional approach focused on reactive support. I challenged this by proposing a proactive support model using predictive analytics to anticipate customer needs. Implementing this innovative approach led to a significant reduction in support tickets and increased customer satisfaction.

39. What strategies do you use to encourage and foster critical thinking among team members or colleagues?

I encourage critical thinking by fostering a collaborative and open environment where diverse perspectives are valued. I use techniques such as brainstorming sessions, critical questioning, and case studies to stimulate thinking. Providing training and resources on critical thinking skills also helps team members develop their abilities.

40. Can you share a situation where your critical thinking skills helped you identify and capitalize on opportunities for growth or expansion?

While analyzing market trends, I identified an emerging demand for eco-friendly products. By leveraging this insight, we developed a new line of sustainable products, tapping into the growing market. This strategic move not only boosted sales but also enhanced our brand's reputation as an environmentally responsible company.

41. How do you handle situations where there are conflicting interests or priorities that require careful consideration and analysis?

I handle conflicting interests by clearly defining each priority's importance and impact. I facilitate discussions with stakeholders to understand their perspectives and use a decision matrix to evaluate options based on criteria such as urgency, feasibility, and alignment with organizational goals. This structured approach ensures balanced and informed decisions.

42. Can you describe a time when you had to evaluate the potential long-term implications of a decision using critical thinking?

When considering an investment in new technology, I evaluated the potential long-term implications, such as scalability, maintenance costs, and impact on existing systems. By conducting a thorough cost-benefit analysis and consulting with experts, I ensured that the decision aligned with our long-term strategic goals and provided sustainable value.

43. What role does data analysis and interpretation play in your critical thinking process?

Data analysis and interpretation are crucial for informed decision-making. They provide evidence to support or refute assumptions and help identify trends, patterns, and correlations. By analyzing and interpreting data, I can draw meaningful conclusions, develop well-supported recommendations, and ensure decisions are based on objective information.

44. Can you give an example of a time when you had to weigh the pros and cons of different courses of action using critical thinking principles?

In a project to reduce operational costs, I had to choose between outsourcing and implementing new technology. I weighed the pros and cons of each option, considering factors such as cost savings, quality control, and implementation time. By evaluating these factors critically, we chose the option that provided the best balance of cost efficiency and quality.

45. How do you approach decision-making in high-pressure or time-sensitive situations using critical thinking?

In high-pressure situations, I prioritize gathering the most critical information quickly and consult with key stakeholders. I use frameworks such as SWOT analysis to assess options and make informed decisions. While I aim for the best possible decision, I remain flexible and ready to adjust as new information becomes available.

46. Can you share a situation where your critical thinking skills helped you identify and address root causes of problems or issues?

In a project experiencing frequent delays, I used critical thinking to analyze the workflow and identify the root causes. I found that poor communication and unclear task assignments were the primary issues. By implementing clear communication protocols and defined roles, we addressed the root causes and improved project timelines.

47. What steps do you take to ensure that your critical thinking process is thorough and comprehensive?

I ensure thoroughness by defining the problem clearly, gathering relevant information from multiple sources, and using analytical tools to evaluate the data. I seek input from diverse perspectives and document my process to identify any gaps. Regularly reviewing and refining my approach ensures a comprehensive and rigorous critical thinking process.

48. Can you describe a time when you had to evaluate the potential risks and benefits of a decision using critical analysis?

When deciding to enter a new market, I evaluated the potential risks and benefits through a detailed market analysis. I assessed factors such as market demand, competition, regulatory environment, and investment requirements. By weighing the risks and benefits, we made an informed decision that minimized potential downsides and maximized opportunities.

49. How do you handle situations where there are competing priorities or constraints that require creative problem-solving and critical thinking?

I handle competing priorities by assessing their importance and impact on organizational goals. I use creative problem-solving techniques such as brainstorming and mind mapping to generate innovative solutions. By evaluating options against constraints and aligning them with strategic objectives, I make decisions that balance competing demands effectively.

50. Can you give an example of a time when your critical thinking skills led to a successful outcome or achievement in your role?

In a cost reduction initiative, I used critical thinking to analyze our supply chain and identify inefficiencies. By negotiating better terms with suppliers and optimizing inventory management, we achieved significant cost savings. This critical analysis and strategic action led to improved profitability and operational efficiency for the organization.

Get More Interviews, Faster

Huntr streamlines your job search. Instantly craft tailored resumes and cover letters, fill out application forms with a single click, effortlessly keep your job hunt organized, and much more...

or learn more

Next-Generation Job Tailored Resumes

Huntr provides the most advanced job <> resume matching system in the world. Helping you match not only keywords, but responsibilities and qualifications from a job, into your resume.

Job Keyword Extractor + Resume AI Integration

Huntr extracts keywords from job descriptions and helps you integrate them into your resume using the power of AI.

Application Autofill

Save hours of mindless form filling. Use our chrome extension to fill application forms with a single click.

Move beyond basic, bare-bones job trackers. Elevate your search with Huntr's all-in-one, feature-rich management platform.

Perfectly tailored cover letters, in seconds! Our cover letter generator blends your unique background with the job's specific requirements, resulting in unique, standout cover letters.

Huntr checks your resume for spelling, length, impactful use of metrics, repetition and more, ensuring your resume gets noticed by employers.

Gorgeous Resume Templates

Stand out with one of 7 designer-grade templates. Whether you're a creative spirit or a corporate professional, our range of templates caters to every career aspiration.

Personal Job Search CRM

The ultimate companion for managing your professional job-search contacts and organizing your job search outreach.

Critical Thinking Interview Questions: 15 Interview Questions to Identify Top Candidates

Critical thinking goes beyond technical expertise and is essential in a wide range of professions. It’s a skill that enables employees to analyze information, solve problems, and make informed decisions. You can gauge critical thinking using assessment tests, practical problem solving, or through crafting interview questions highlighting critical thinking abilities.

In this blog, we’ll be going through questions you can ask your candidates to figure out if they have the critical thinking skills you require for your open position. But first, let’s talk about why critical thinking skills are so important.  

Why Are Critical Thinking Skills Necessary?

Critical thinkers are especially necessary positions that require problem solving skills, juggling various priorities, and analyzing data. Although many jobs and industries require a certain level of critical thinking ability, these skills are essential for some job roles and industries, including:

• K-12 : The best teachers are creative problem solvers. Between classroom management and learning fatigue, critical thinking skills help teachers find the best way to connect with their students.
• Leadership Positions : Effective leaders must make strategic decisions, often in ambiguous situations. Critical thinking is crucial in leadership roles.
• Creative Fields : In industries such as design, advertising, and content creation, the ability to think critically allows individuals to come up with innovative and unique solutions and ways to attract prospective customers.
• Healthcare : Medical professionals must critically assess patient conditions, interpret test results, and make decisions that can have a significant impact on a patient’s well-being.
• Technology : IT professionals, software developers, and data analysts rely on critical thinking to troubleshoot, create algorithms, and analyze data.

Now, let’s dive into a list of interview questions that can help you evaluate a candidate’s critical thinking abilities.  

Interview Questions to Assess Critical Thinking:

Note: Feel free to mix and match these questions based on the specific role and the level of critical thinking required. Also–to expand on questions like these, you can use tools like AI Question Assist . interviewstream’s Ethical AI tool helps you come up with position and industry-based questions using community knowledge from a large language

• Tell me about a situation where you faced a complex problem at work? How did you approach it, and what was the outcome?
• How do you typically approach a new project or task? What steps do you take to understand the problem and develop a plan?
• Give an example of a situation where you had to think on your feet and adapt to unexpected challenges.
• Describe a project where you had to evaluate multiple options before making a decision. How did you assess the pros and cons?
• Provide an instance where you identified a problem in your current or previous role that others might have overlooked? What did you do about it?
• What methods do you use to gather and evaluate information when solving complex issues?
• Tell me about a situation where you had to analyze data to make a decision. What tools or methodologies did you use?
• Describe a project where you had to anticipate potential obstacles and develop contingency plans. How did your proactive thinking benefit the project?
• Provide an example of a time when you identified a solution that significantly improved a process or operation at your company?
• Describe a situation where you had to explain a complex concept or solution to someone who had little to no knowledge of the subject. How did you ensure effective communication?
• How do you prioritize tasks and allocate your time when dealing with multiple projects or assignments?
• Explain your process for identifying the root cause of a problem. Can you provide an example from your experience?
• Describe a project where you had to innovate and think outside the box to overcome a challenge or reach a goal?
• Tell me about a time when you had to analyze financial data or budgets to make recommendations or decisions for your department or company.
• How do you approach a project that requires you to think long-term and consider the potential future implications of your decisions?

How to Use Critical Thinking Interview Questions in your Interviewing Process

The ability to think critically and solve complex problems is relevant across a wide range of job roles and industries. You can use the questions above to assess the critical thinking abilities of your candidates. And you can assess those skills even better if you ask these questions in an in-person or video interview .

Especially if you are using these questions in screening interviews , video screening is an effective way to see the candidate process critical thinking questions in real time. For more information on interview questions, we wrote an article on the best interview questions to ask for team players , or you can fill out this form to chat with us today about how interviewstream can help you ask the right questions, every time.

About The Author

Caroline Chessia is the Marketing Operations Specialist at interviewstream. She loves color-coordinated graphs, hiking in the mountains, and every dog she meets—especially the Golden Retrievers.

For over 20 years, interviewstream has been committed to driving hiring success for a diverse range of clients, including K-12 school districts, healthcare organizations, government agencies, emerging businesses, mid-sized companies, large enterprises, and institutions of higher education.

• Building Interview Process
• On Demand Interviews
• Interview Scheduling
• Hiring Event Interview Scheduling
• Live Video Interviews
• Interview Insights
• Continuity Plan
• Terms of Service
• Privacy Policy
• Cookie Policy
• Single Sign-On

877-773-3164 (USA Only) [email protected] Support

Top 20 Critical Thinking Interview Questions & Answers

Master your responses to Critical Thinking related interview questions with our example questions and answers. Boost your chances of landing the job by learning how to effectively communicate your Critical Thinking capabilities.

Critical thinking is a skill highly sought after in today’s complex and fast-paced world. It’s not merely about thinking clearly or rationally; it’s about analyzing and evaluating information to guide action, making it pivotal across all professions and industries. Whether you are applying for a role that explicitly lists critical thinking as a job requirement or you’re looking to enhance your problem-solving prowess in your current position, demonstrating strong critical thinking skills can set you apart from the competition.

This article aims to illuminate the significance of critical thinking in the professional realm by delving into interview questions designed to test this indispensable skill. We’ll provide insights into what employers are looking for when they assess critical thinking abilities and offer strategies for crafting responses that showcase your analytical acumen.

Common Critical Thinking Interview Questions

1. how would you differentiate between a problem that requires critical thinking and one that does not.

Navigating ambiguous situations and analyzing information objectively are key components of effective critical thinking. This skill is crucial for solving complex problems where standard protocols may not apply, and outcomes are unpredictable. Conversely, routine problems often have established methods and clear-cut solutions that don’t demand extensive analysis or creative thought. The question aims to assess a candidate’s ability to recognize when a nuanced approach is necessary versus when efficiency can be prioritized by following standard procedures. It also evaluates a candidate’s judgment in identifying the scale and impact of a problem, which is crucial for resource management and prioritization within a role.

When responding, a candidate should outline their thought process for assessing problems, highlighting their ability to identify key factors such as the complexity of the issue, potential risks, and the level of uncertainty involved. An effective response would include examples demonstrating how they have distinguished between routine and complex problems in past experiences, along with the strategies they employed to address each effectively. This showcases their problem-solving abilities and their understanding of when to leverage critical thinking skills.

Example: “ Differentiating between a problem that requires critical thinking and one that does not hinges on the analysis of several dimensions of the problem at hand. For instance, a problem that is routine, well-defined, and has a clear set of procedures or historical precedents for its resolution typically may not necessitate critical thinking. In contrast, a problem that is complex, ambiguous, involves multiple stakeholders with conflicting interests, or has significant consequences depending on the outcome, demands a critical thinking approach.

In practice, I assess the need for critical thinking by evaluating the problem’s novelty, the scope of impact, the level of uncertainty, and the interdependencies among variables. For example, when faced with a new market trend that could potentially disrupt our business model, I recognized this as a critical thinking scenario due to its complexity and high stakes. I systematically gathered and analyzed data, questioned assumptions, and explored alternative solutions. This involved not just an analytical breakdown of the problem but also creative synthesis to develop innovative strategies, demonstrating the application of critical thinking to navigate through the intricacies of the issue effectively.”

2. Describe an instance when your initial hypothesis about a complex issue was incorrect.

When it comes to critical thinking, the ability to form hypotheses and adjust them when presented with new information or evidence is fundamental. This question delves into a candidate’s flexibility of thought, their willingness to admit and learn from mistakes, and their capacity to approach problems from multiple angles. A well-rounded candidate will not only recognize when they are wrong but will also see it as an opportunity for growth rather than a setback. It’s a test of humility and intellectual integrity, key traits for roles demanding analytical prowess and decision-making.

In your response, recount a specific situation where you had to pivot from your original assumption. Briefly outline the context and the stakes involved. Then, focus on the process you underwent to re-evaluate the situation: the additional information you considered, the way you integrated new data, and how you ultimately arrived at a different conclusion. Emphasize your thought process and the lessons learned, ensuring you highlight your adaptability and continuous improvement mindset.

Example: “ In analyzing a complex issue within a project, my initial hypothesis was that the bottleneck was caused by an inefficiency in the operational workflow. Upon deeper analysis, however, I discovered that the issue was not the workflow itself but rather a mismatch in team skill sets and resource allocation. By incorporating data analytics and soliciting cross-departmental feedback, I realized that the workflow was designed optimally but was being executed by team members who were not best suited for their roles.

To address this, I facilitated a realignment of tasks to match individual strengths and brought in additional training for areas where the team was lacking expertise. This pivot not only resolved the bottleneck but also improved overall team performance and morale. The experience underscored the importance of a data-driven approach and the value of looking beyond surface-level symptoms to underlying causes. It also reinforced the necessity of maintaining a flexible mindset and being willing to challenge my own assumptions in the face of new evidence.”

3. What strategies do you employ to identify biases in your decision-making process?

Awareness of personal biases is a critical component of effective critical thinking. Recognizing and mitigating these biases ensures that decisions are based on objective analysis rather than subjective preference. This question aims to assess whether a candidate is self-aware and actively engaged in personal development, as well as their ability to maintain objectivity in professional scenarios. It also speaks to a candidate’s commitment to fairness and their potential for leadership, where unbiased decision-making is essential for team cohesion and trust.

When responding, candidates should articulate the specific techniques they use to keep their biases in check. This might include seeking diverse perspectives, consulting with colleagues, relying on data and evidence, or engaging in reflective practices such as journaling or meditation. Candidates should provide concrete examples of when they’ve identified a bias in their thinking and how they adjusted their approach to ensure a more balanced outcome. Demonstrating a proactive approach to personal growth and a dedication to fair decision-making will signal to interviewers a candidate’s suitability for roles requiring sound judgment.

Example: “ To identify biases in my decision-making process, I employ a combination of reflective practices and evidence-based evaluation. I actively engage in self-reflection to question my initial assumptions and consider the origins of my perspectives. This often involves journaling, which helps to externalize and critically assess my thought patterns. Additionally, I prioritize the collection and analysis of data to inform my decisions, ensuring that they are rooted in objective evidence rather than subjective intuition.

When I detect a potential bias, I seek out diverse viewpoints to challenge my preconceptions. This involves consulting with colleagues who may have different experiences or expertise, which provides a broader perspective and mitigates the risk of echo chambers. In a recent project, I recognized a confirmation bias in my analysis, where I was favoring information that supported my initial hypothesis. By acknowledging this, I revisited the data and actively searched for disconfirming evidence, which led to a more nuanced understanding and ultimately a more robust decision-making process. This approach not only enhances the quality of my decisions but also fosters a culture of critical thinking and continuous improvement.”

4. In what ways have you used critical thinking to improve a process at your previous job?

Dissecting a process, analyzing its components with a sharp eye, and envisioning a more efficient or effective method are all aspects of critical thinking that drive process improvement and innovation. This ability to objectively evaluate and enhance systems is not just about fixing what’s broken, but also about preempting potential issues and maximizing productivity. By asking this question, interviewers are looking for evidence of a candidate’s analytical skills and their initiative to bring about positive change within an organization.

When responding to this question, provide a concrete example of a time you identified a problem or area for improvement. Break down the steps you took to analyze the situation, emphasizing how you gathered data, considered various solutions, and weighed the pros and cons. Then, explain the action you took, the implementation of the new process, and most importantly, the outcome. Illustrate how your critical thinking led to tangible benefits for the company, such as time savings, cost reductions, increased revenue, or improved employee satisfaction.

Example: “ In a previous role, I identified a bottleneck in our project reporting process, which was causing delays in decision-making. I initiated a thorough analysis of the existing workflow and discovered that the report consolidation was the primary issue, as it relied on manual data entry from multiple departments. To tackle this, I conducted a root cause analysis to understand the underlying issues and engaged with stakeholders to gather insights and validate findings.

Armed with this information, I proposed and implemented an automated data aggregation tool that interfaced with our existing systems. This solution not only streamlined the data collection process but also reduced the potential for human error. By critically evaluating the process and considering the technological resources available, I was able to re-engineer the workflow, resulting in a 30% reduction in the time taken to generate reports. This improvement led to faster strategic decisions and a significant increase in overall team productivity.”

5. Can you provide an example of how you’ve dissected a multifaceted argument to assess its validity?

Breaking down complex issues into their component parts to understand the underlying logic and reasoning is a hallmark of effective critical thinking. This skill is particularly valuable as it allows for a nuanced approach to problem-solving, where the thinker can identify biases, logical fallacies, and the strength of the evidence presented. Employers seek individuals who can navigate through layers of information, differentiate between correlation and causation, and make informed decisions based on a sound analysis of available data. This question aims to reveal whether the candidate has a systematic approach to addressing intricate arguments and can remain objective while evaluating differing viewpoints.

When responding to this question, begin by outlining a specific scenario where you were faced with a challenging argument or problem. Walk the interviewer through your process step-by-step, explaining how you identified key issues, researched relevant information, and applied logical reasoning to each part. Highlight how you remained impartial, even if the argument related to a topic you felt strongly about, and conclude by sharing the outcome of your analysis. This approach not only demonstrates your critical thinking abilities but also shows that you can communicate complex ideas clearly and effectively.

Example: “ In one instance, I was presented with an argument that a particular business strategy would significantly increase market share. The argument was supported by a variety of data points and expert opinions. To assess its validity, I first deconstructed the argument into its core components: the underlying assumptions, the evidence provided, and the logical connections between the two.

I then conducted an independent evaluation of the evidence, scrutinizing the methodology behind the data collection and the credibility of the sources. Simultaneously, I challenged the assumptions by considering alternative scenarios and seeking out information that could either confirm or refute them. Throughout this process, I maintained an objective stance, ensuring that my personal biases did not color the analysis.

The outcome of this rigorous examination was a nuanced understanding of the strategy’s potential. I concluded that while the strategy had merit, it also carried risks that were not initially apparent. This comprehensive analysis allowed for a more informed decision-making process that considered both the strengths and weaknesses of the proposed strategy.”

6. Outline the steps you take when confronted with conflicting data points.

When presented with conflicting data, the ability to discern, analyze, and integrate information is paramount. This question not only assesses a candidate’s analytical skills but also evaluates their approach to uncertainty and complexity. It inspects the candidate’s methodology for handling information that doesn’t readily align, testing their intellectual rigor and commitment to evidence-based decision-making.

To respond, outline a systematic approach: begin by verifying the sources of the data for credibility. Next, cross-examine the information for errors or biases. If the data remains conflicting, consider alternative perspectives or additional research to provide context. Explain how you would weigh the evidence, perhaps employing specific analytical tools or consulting with knowledgeable colleagues. Conclude by describing how you would form a reasoned conclusion or make a recommendation, emphasizing your flexibility and openness to changing your stance as new information arises.

Example: “ When confronted with conflicting data points, my initial step is to authenticate the sources, ensuring their reliability and validity. I scrutinize the methodologies used to gather the data, looking for potential errors or methodological inconsistencies that could explain the discrepancies. If the sources and methods are sound, I proceed to examine the data for any inherent biases or contextual factors that might influence the results.

Following this critical evaluation, I explore additional research or data that could provide further insight, often utilizing statistical analysis or predictive modeling to discern patterns or anomalies. This process may also involve seeking expertise from colleagues who can offer alternative perspectives or specialized knowledge. Throughout this investigative phase, I maintain a balanced approach, considering all evidence on its merit.

Ultimately, I synthesize the findings, weighing the evidence carefully. My recommendation or conclusion is based on the most comprehensive and robust understanding of the data, with an acknowledgment of any remaining uncertainties. I remain adaptable, ready to adjust my position in light of new evidence or insights that may emerge.”

7. When evaluating evidence, how do you determine its relevance and reliability?

Analyzing information and making informed decisions hinge on determining the relevance and reliability of evidence. The question delves into the candidate’s thought process and methodology for discerning the quality and applicability of information. It also reveals their capacity for skepticism and due diligence, as well as their understanding of the sources and contexts that may affect the integrity of evidence. Employers ask this to ensure the potential employee can effectively sift through data, recognize biases, and draw conclusions that are not only logical but also empirically sound.

When responding to this question, a candidate should outline a systematic approach, starting with the assessment of the source’s credibility, including its origin, authorship, and purpose. They should then discuss the process of cross-referencing the information with other reliable sources and the importance of considering the context in which the evidence was produced. Demonstrating an awareness of one’s own cognitive biases and the potential for these to influence decision-making is also valuable. Lastly, articulating a clear, practical example of how they have applied these principles in a previous situation can help to solidify their response.

Example: “ In evaluating evidence, the first step is to scrutinize the source’s credibility. This includes examining the author’s qualifications, the publication’s reputation, and the methodology used to gather the information. I then assess the purpose of the evidence, looking for any signs of bias or intent to persuade rather than inform. To establish reliability, I cross-reference the evidence with other sources, ensuring they are independent and authoritative. This triangulation helps to confirm the consistency and validity of the information.

Context is paramount; understanding the circumstances under which the evidence was produced allows for a more nuanced interpretation. For instance, in a previous situation where I had to evaluate data from a study, I considered the sample size, the controls in place, and the study’s funding sources. Moreover, I remain vigilant about my cognitive biases, actively seeking disconfirming evidence to challenge my initial conclusions. This disciplined approach ensures that my decisions are based on robust and objective assessments of the evidence at hand.”

8. Share an experience where you had to make a decision without all the desired information.

Acting with confidence even when not all the facts are present is a common requirement in fast-paced environments where waiting for perfect information could lead to missed opportunities or compounded issues. The question aims to assess a candidate’s risk assessment capabilities, their comfort with ambiguity, and their problem-solving skills. It evaluates whether the candidate can pull from their knowledge, past experiences, and available resources to make an informed decision that could potentially affect the outcome of a project or the direction of a company.

When responding to this question, candidates should focus on a specific example that showcases their thought process during an uncertain situation. They should detail the steps they took to gather as much information as possible, weigh the potential risks and benefits, consider the impact of their decision, and explain how they arrived at their conclusion. It’s also beneficial to reflect on the outcome of the decision and what they learned from the experience, demonstrating an ability to learn and adapt from less-than-ideal situations.

Example: “ In a project where time-sensitive decisions were crucial, I encountered a situation where critical data was incomplete due to unforeseen circumstances. Understanding the urgency, I initiated a rapid but thorough risk assessment to evaluate potential impacts of various decision scenarios. I leveraged historical data, parallel case studies, and consulted with subject matter experts to fill in informational gaps to the greatest extent possible.

After synthesizing this information, I employed a decision matrix to prioritize options based on the project’s strategic objectives and stakeholder interests. I chose a course of action that balanced risk with potential reward, ensuring that the most critical project deliverables remained on track. The decision was successful, resulting in minimal disruption to the project timeline and budget. This experience reinforced the importance of a structured approach to decision-making under uncertainty and the value of drawing on diverse information sources to inform such decisions.”

9. Detail a situation in which your critical analysis led to a significant change in strategy or direction.

Strategic planning and problem-solving are areas where critical thinking is indispensable. When interviewers pose this question, they’re looking for evidence of your ability to dissect complex issues, consider diverse perspectives, and foresee potential outcomes. The ability to pivot and adapt strategies based on new information reflects an agile mindset, which is highly valued in dynamic business environments. It reveals your capacity to influence meaningful change and demonstrates foresight, adaptability, and the courage to challenge the status quo when necessary.

When responding, outline a specific scenario succinctly, emphasizing the complexity of the situation and the critical thinking processes you employed. Discuss the rationale behind your analysis, the different options you considered, and why you advocated for a particular change in strategy or direction. Highlight the impact of your decision—how it benefited the organization, improved efficiency, increased revenue, or mitigated risks. Your response should convey confidence in your judgment, an analytical approach to problem-solving, and a proactive stance in driving innovation or improvement.

Example: “ In a project where the initial strategy was to expand market share through aggressive pricing, I conducted a critical analysis of market trends, consumer behavior, and competitive responses. My analysis revealed that such a pricing strategy would trigger a price war with competitors that our company was not financially positioned to sustain. Instead, I proposed a value-added approach, focusing on differentiating our products through enhanced features and customer service rather than competing solely on price.

I presented a comprehensive business case to the leadership team, outlining the potential long-term consequences of the original strategy, including market erosion and reduced profitability. I contrasted this with the projected outcomes of the value-added strategy, which included increased customer loyalty, brand strength, and sustainable profit margins. The leadership adopted my recommendation, leading to a 15% increase in customer retention and a 10% rise in profit margins within the following fiscal year, validating the shift in strategy and demonstrating the importance of thorough critical analysis in strategic decision-making.”

10. How do you handle situations where team members resist your critical evaluations?

Providing feedback that may not be readily accepted, especially when it challenges established ideas or practices within a team, involves effective critical thinking. The ability to navigate resistance is a testament to one’s diplomatic skills and emotional intelligence. It reflects an understanding that critique is not a personal attack but a necessary part of growth and innovation. Employers value candidates who can diplomatically deliver critical evaluations and facilitate a constructive dialogue that leads to improved performance and collaboration, rather than discord and division.

When responding to this question, it’s important to emphasize your approach to communication and conflict resolution. Detail specific strategies you employ to ensure that your evaluations are objective, evidence-based, and presented in a way that underscores their intention to improve the team’s output. Highlight your ability to listen to and address concerns, foster an open environment for discussion, and ultimately guide the team towards a consensus or compromise that upholds the project’s best interests.

Example: “ In situations where team members resist critical evaluations, my approach is to first ensure that the feedback is grounded in objective data and aligns with predefined goals or standards. I present my evaluations with clarity, focusing on the issue at hand rather than personal attributes, to minimize defensiveness. When resistance occurs, I actively listen to the team members’ perspectives, acknowledging their viewpoints and concerns. This demonstrates respect for their expertise and fosters an environment of mutual trust.

I then facilitate a constructive dialogue, guiding the team towards understanding the evaluation’s rationale and the potential benefits of addressing the identified issues. By encouraging an open exchange of ideas, I often find that resistance gives way to collaborative problem-solving. If a consensus is not immediately reached, I propose incremental steps to test the recommended changes, allowing the team to see empirical results. This method not only validates the evaluation’s findings but also empowers the team to be part of the solution, ensuring that the critical evaluation serves as a catalyst for positive change rather than a point of contention.”

11. What is your approach to prioritizing issues requiring immediate critical thought over routine tasks?

Distinguishing between tasks that need immediate attention and those that follow a routine is often a critical component of professional critical thinking. Employers are looking for candidates who can swiftly analyze situations, recognize the urgency and potential impact of each task, and act accordingly to ensure efficiency and effectiveness. The ability to prioritize reflects a person’s judgment, time management skills, and ultimately their capability to contribute to the organization’s success without becoming overwhelmed or sacrificing quality.

When responding to this question, you should demonstrate your decision-making process by providing a clear and structured approach. Outline how you assess the importance of tasks, perhaps by considering factors such as deadlines, potential outcomes, and resources required. You could also mention any tools or techniques you use to stay organized, such as to-do lists or project management software. Giving concrete examples from past experiences where you successfully prioritized critical issues will illustrate your methodology in action and reassure the interviewer of your proficiency in this area.

Example: “ When faced with multiple tasks, my approach to prioritization begins with a swift evaluation of each issue’s potential impact and urgency. I consider the consequences of delayed action, weighing the risks against the benefits of immediate attention. Critical issues that could escalate into larger problems or have a significant negative impact on the project or organization take precedence. For instance, if a critical issue has the potential to disrupt service delivery or cause financial loss, it becomes the top priority.

I utilize a combination of Eisenhower’s Matrix for categorizing tasks by urgency and importance, and project management tools for tracking progress and deadlines. This method allows me to maintain a clear overview of the landscape of responsibilities and make informed decisions quickly. In practice, this approach has enabled me to effectively intervene in situations that required immediate critical thought, such as resolving a bottleneck in a project that threatened to derail the timeline, while ensuring that routine tasks are rescheduled appropriately and do not fall by the wayside.”

12. Could you give an example of a time when you had to challenge conventional wisdom using critical thinking?

The ability to step outside the norm, question the status quo, and innovate is a key aspect of critical thinking. This question aims to unearth a candidate’s ability to recognize when a widely accepted approach is flawed or inadequate and their courage and skill in devising and implementing a more effective alternative. It reveals their capability to not only recognize when a widely accepted approach is flawed or inadequate but also their courage and skill in devising and implementing a more effective alternative.

To respond effectively, choose a specific instance where you identified a problem that others had accepted as unsolvable or ignored due to traditional thinking. Explain your thought process in evaluating the situation, how you identified a novel approach, and the steps you took to challenge the prevailing wisdom. Highlight the outcome, what you learned, and how it demonstrates your critical thinking prowess. Be sure to convey confidence in your decision-making process while also acknowledging the risk and resistance that often accompanies going against the grain.

Example: “ In a project where the prevailing approach was to incrementally improve an existing product, I noticed that our incremental changes were no longer yielding significant benefits to the customer. Conventional wisdom suggested we continue with minor improvements, but my analysis of customer feedback and market trends indicated a plateau in satisfaction and a shift in consumer needs.

Using critical thinking, I dissected the core functions of our product, reevaluated our assumptions, and proposed a radical redesign that aligned more closely with emerging user preferences. I presented a data-driven case to stakeholders, illustrating the long-term benefits and potential market capture that a bold move could offer. Despite initial resistance, the evidence was compelling, and we pivoted to the new strategy.

The redesigned product not only reinvigorated the brand but also captured a new customer segment, leading to a substantial increase in market share. This experience underscored the importance of questioning the status quo and reinforced my belief in the power of critical thinking to drive innovation and strategic redirection.”

13. How do you maintain objectivity when critically assessing emotionally charged issues?

Detaching oneself from personal biases and emotional influences to arrive at logical, fair conclusions is a demand of critical thinking, especially in emotionally charged situations. Employers ask this question to discern whether a candidate possesses the self-awareness and strategies necessary to navigate emotionally-laden terrain without compromising their decision-making process. It’s a subtle test of a candidate’s professionalism and their capacity to handle workplace conflicts or sensitive projects with a level head.

When responding, illustrate with examples where you’ve successfully maintained impartiality during heated discussions or decisions. Emphasize techniques you use, such as stepping back to analyze the facts, seeking diverse perspectives, or employing established frameworks to guide your thought process. Your answer should reassure the interviewer that you can uphold the integrity of your role, even when emotions run high.

Example: “ Maintaining objectivity in emotionally charged situations hinges on a disciplined adherence to evidence and a structured analytical framework. For instance, during a contentious project debate, I anchor my assessment in data-driven criteria, ensuring that decisions are rooted in quantifiable metrics rather than subjective sentiments. This approach not only clarifies the decision-making process but also provides a common language for all stakeholders, facilitating a more rational discourse.

Additionally, I actively seek out diverse perspectives to challenge my own biases and broaden my understanding of the issue at hand. By engaging with viewpoints that differ from my own, I can construct a more comprehensive analysis that transcends personal emotions. This method was particularly effective when navigating a high-stakes negotiation, where synthesizing the various interests led to a consensus that balanced emotional concerns with strategic objectives. Employing these techniques consistently has proven to be instrumental in upholding impartiality and ensuring that critical thinking prevails in emotionally intense scenarios.”

14. What techniques do you use to foster critical thinking skills within a team environment?

Cultivating an environment where team members are encouraged to think deeply and challenge assumptions is a reflection of critical thinking in a team setting. When interviewers pose this question, they are looking for insight into how you foster intellectual growth and collaborative problem-solving. It reveals your leadership style and your ability to facilitate intellectual growth and collaborative problem-solving. The question also serves to understand if you can balance the need for diverse perspectives while steering the team towards cohesive, well-reasoned outcomes.

When responding, you should outline specific strategies you’ve employed to encourage critical thinking. This could include fostering open discussions, posing challenging problems for the team to solve, encouraging team members to question the status quo, and facilitating debates. Highlight examples from your experience where these techniques have led to innovative solutions or improved decision-making. Mention how you ensure all voices are heard and how you guide discussions to remain constructive and focused on the end goal.

Example: “ To cultivate critical thinking within a team, I implement a structured approach to problem-solving that encourages divergent thinking followed by convergent analysis. Initially, I facilitate brainstorming sessions that promote the free flow of ideas without immediate judgment, allowing team members to explore various perspectives and challenge preconceived notions. This openness fosters an environment where creativity is valued, and unconventional ideas can surface.

Once a broad range of ideas is on the table, I guide the team through a critical evaluation process. This involves systematically assessing the feasibility, potential impact, and risks associated with each idea. I encourage team members to ask probing questions and consider the implications of each approach. By employing techniques such as the Six Thinking Hats or SWOT analysis, I ensure that the team examines issues from multiple angles, leading to more robust and well-rounded solutions. Moreover, I make a conscious effort to create an inclusive atmosphere where every member feels empowered to contribute, ensuring a diversity of thought and preventing groupthink. Through these methods, we’ve consistently achieved innovative outcomes and enhanced our collective decision-making capabilities.”

15. Illustrate how you balance quick decision-making with thorough critical analysis under pressure.

Thinking on one’s feet while ensuring that decisions are well-considered and not rash is a crucial aspect of critical thinking, especially in roles where the stakes are high and the cost of a mistake is significant. Employers ask this question to assess a candidate’s ability to think on their feet while also ensuring that their decisions are well-considered and not rash. It’s crucial in roles where the stakes are high and the cost of a mistake is significant. The interviewer is looking for a glimpse into your decision-making process, particularly how you weigh the urgency of a situation against the need for comprehensive analysis.

To respond, describe a scenario where you were faced with a time-sensitive decision. Walk through your thought process, highlighting how you identified the key issues, evaluated the information at hand, and prioritized actions while maintaining a commitment to making a sound, well-reasoned choice. Focus on demonstrating your ability to discern which decisions require immediate action and which can benefit from more extensive analysis. It’s important to convey that you can strike a balance between speed and precision, leveraging your critical thinking skills to deliver optimal outcomes efficiently.

Example: “ In a situation where rapid decision-making was crucial, I employed a tiered approach to critical analysis. Initially, I identified the core issue that demanded immediate attention, separating it from less urgent factors. I then quickly gathered the most relevant data, applying heuristic techniques to assess the situation’s urgency and potential impact. This allowed me to prioritize actions that would mitigate immediate risks or capitalize on fleeting opportunities.

Simultaneously, I maintained an awareness of the broader context, ensuring that my swift decisions aligned with long-term objectives and values. By leveraging a combination of deductive reasoning to address the immediate issue and inductive reasoning to consider the potential implications, I was able to make a well-reasoned decision that was both timely and thoughtful. This method has consistently proven effective in balancing the need for expediency with the commitment to thorough analysis, ensuring that the decisions I make under pressure are both strategic and sound.”

16. Have you ever encountered a groupthink scenario and how did you apply critical thinking to address it?

Recognizing the signs of groupthink—such as a homogenization of ideas, pressure to conform, and an illusion of unanimity—and challenging the status quo to ensure diverse perspectives are considered is important for preventing suboptimal outcomes. Employers value candidates who can maintain objectivity, apply analytical skills to evaluate different opinions, and foster a culture of open dialogue, even when it’s uncomfortable or goes against the grain. This question assesses a candidate’s ability to maintain objectivity, apply analytical skills to evaluate different opinions, and foster a culture of open dialogue, even when it’s uncomfortable or goes against the grain.

When responding, it’s important to provide a specific example that illustrates your awareness of a groupthink situation. Detail how you identified the issue, the steps you took to encourage alternative viewpoints, and the outcome of your intervention. Emphasize your communication skills, your respect for diverse opinions, and your commitment to making decisions based on evidence and sound reasoning. It’s also beneficial to reflect on what you learned from the experience and how it has influenced your approach to teamwork and problem-solving in subsequent situations.

Example: “ Yes, I encountered a groupthink scenario during a project where the team was prematurely converging on a solution without thoroughly vetting alternatives. Recognizing the signs of groupthink, such as the lack of debate and the quick dismissal of outside opinions, I intervened by orchestrating a structured brainstorming session. I introduced a “devil’s advocate” approach, assigning team members to purposely challenge the prevailing assumptions and propose contrarian viewpoints.

This strategy fostered a more open dialogue and encouraged critical evaluation of the proposed solution. By systematically dissecting each argument and examining the evidence, the team was able to identify potential flaws and biases in our initial approach. The outcome was a more robust and innovative solution that had the benefit of diverse perspectives. The experience reinforced the importance of vigilance against groupthink and has since shaped my commitment to fostering an environment where critical thinking and dissenting opinions are valued in the decision-making process.”

17. Describe a complex project where your critical thinking uncovered an overlooked solution.

Evaluating sources, such as data, facts, observable phenomena, and research findings, is part of the critical thinking process. In the context of a job interview, this question serves to evaluate not only a candidate’s problem-solving capabilities but also their initiative and innovation. It reveals how a candidate approaches a problem, breaks it down into components, and systematically tackles it. It’s about assessing the candidate’s ability to not just think, but to think outside the box and recognize patterns that are not immediately obvious, which can lead to innovative solutions that others might miss.

When responding to this question, you should outline the context of the project briefly, highlighting its complexity. Proceed to explain the thought process you employed, detailing how you identified the problem, the various solutions you considered, and why they were dismissed or pursued. Emphasize the critical thinking techniques you used, such as questioning assumptions, analyzing potential outcomes, and synthesizing information from various sources. Conclude with the impact of your solution, such as cost savings, time efficiency, or improved outcomes. Demonstrating a structured approach to problem-solving will show employers that you possess the analytical skills necessary to tackle complex projects effectively.

Example: “ In a recent complex project, the primary challenge was optimizing the resource allocation process to reduce waste and increase efficiency. The existing system was sophisticated but had a persistent issue with over-provisioning, leading to significant financial drain. Upon a deep dive into the data and processes, I employed root cause analysis and discovered that the algorithm driving the allocation was based on outdated assumptions about usage patterns.

By questioning these assumptions and conducting a series of predictive analyses, I proposed a dynamic allocation model that adjusted resources in real-time based on current demand rather than historical trends. I also integrated a feedback loop that allowed the system to learn and adapt over time. This solution required a nuanced understanding of both the technical aspects and the behavioral patterns of system users. The implementation of this model led to a 20% reduction in resource waste within the first quarter, validating the effectiveness of the critical thinking process in uncovering this overlooked solution.”

18. What methods do you utilize to ensure your conclusions are sound when dealing with abstract concepts?

Dissecting and navigating theoretical or complex ideas ensures that a candidate’s thought process is logical, thorough, and evidence-based. The question seeks to explore a candidate’s ability to handle abstract concepts that are not easily quantifiable or observable. It is a test of not just intelligence but of a systematic and disciplined approach to problem-solving that can greatly affect the outcomes of projects and tasks. The interviewer is looking for a glimpse into the candidate’s intellectual rigor and how they handle ambiguity and uncertainty.

When responding, it is vital to discuss a structured approach to critical thinking. One could highlight the importance of questioning assumptions, seeking out a variety of sources for information, and applying logical reasoning. Emphasize the use of specific strategies such as breaking down complex problems into smaller, more manageable parts, employing analogies to better understand unfamiliar concepts, or using decision-making frameworks like the Cynefin framework to categorize problems and respond appropriately. Sharing examples from past experiences where these methods were applied to reach a well-reasoned conclusion can illustrate your proficiency in critical thinking.

Example: “ To ensure my conclusions are sound when dealing with abstract concepts, I systematically employ a combination of deductive and inductive reasoning, while rigorously questioning underlying assumptions. I begin by dissecting the abstract concept into its fundamental elements, which allows me to analyze the problem more effectively. This process of decomposition helps to identify any logical inconsistencies and to understand the relationships between the various components of the concept.

I also draw upon diverse informational sources to inform my understanding, ensuring that my perspective is not limited by a single viewpoint. By integrating these perspectives, I can construct a more comprehensive understanding of the abstract concept. Additionally, I use analogies to create parallels with more familiar concepts, which aids in grasping the essence of the abstract idea and in communicating my reasoning to others. When synthesizing my conclusion, I apply decision-making frameworks like the Cynefin framework, which assists in categorizing the problem and determining the most suitable approach for resolution. This structured methodology ensures that my conclusions are not only logical but also pragmatic, taking into account the complexity and context of the situation at hand.”

19. How do you integrate critical thinking into your everyday work routines?

Anticipating challenges and mitigating them before they impact the workflow is a key aspect of critical thinking. Employers want to know that a candidate can not only solve problems when they arise but also anticipate challenges and mitigate them before they impact the workflow. They are looking for evidence of a proactive mindset that employs logic, creativity, and strategic planning as part of the daily work routine rather than reactive thinking that only addresses issues as they come up.

When responding, candidates should describe specific strategies they use to apply critical thinking in their work. This might involve breaking down complex projects into manageable parts, asking probing questions to fully understand a situation, employing data-driven decision-making, or conducting regular reviews of processes to identify potential improvements. Sharing concrete examples of past situations where critical thinking led to successful outcomes can also demonstrate the candidate’s ability to effectively integrate this skill into their work habits.

Example: “ In my daily work, I routinely employ a methodical approach to problem-solving that hinges on breaking down complex issues into their fundamental components. This dissection allows for a clearer understanding of the underlying factors and variables at play. By doing so, I can systematically evaluate each element, considering both short-term and long-term implications, which is critical for informed decision-making.

I also maintain a disciplined practice of asking probing questions, not only to clarify the specifics of a challenge but also to uncover any hidden assumptions or biases that might skew my analysis. This practice is complemented by a commitment to data-driven decisions, ensuring that my conclusions are grounded in empirical evidence rather than conjecture. To ensure continuous improvement, I conduct regular process reviews, identifying areas for refinement or innovation, thereby fostering a dynamic and responsive work environment that leverages critical thinking to overcome obstacles and enhance productivity.”

20. Reflect on a time when your critical thinking abilities significantly impacted the outcome of a project.

Determining if a candidate can discern complex situations and act in a manner that leads to effective and innovative solutions is a crucial part of the interview process. Employers ask this question to determine if a candidate can not only discern complex situations but also act in a manner that leads to effective and innovative solutions. They are looking for evidence of a methodical approach to tackling challenges and the ability to anticipate potential pitfalls. This question also serves to highlight the candidate’s capacity for reflection and learning from past experiences, which is essential for continuous improvement and adaptability in a dynamic work environment.

When responding to this question, it’s crucial to outline a specific situation that showcases your critical thinking process. Begin by setting the scene and describing the challenge or project at hand. Then, explain the steps you took to analyze the situation, including any data gathering, research, or consultation with experts. Highlight how you weighed different options, considered the consequences, and came to a reasoned decision. Conclude with the outcome, focusing on the positive impact of your critical thinking skills on the project’s success, and if applicable, what you learned from the experience that has influenced your approach to future challenges.

Example: “ In a recent project, we faced a critical decision point when unexpected data discrepancies threatened to derail our progress. The initial analysis suggested a significant flaw in our methodology, which could have led to a complete overhaul of the project. Instead of hastily jumping to conclusions, I initiated a systematic review of our data collection and analysis processes. By breaking down each step, I identified a subtle but consistent error in the way certain data points were being recorded, which skewed our results.

After pinpointing the issue, I proposed a recalibration of our data input protocols and a reanalysis of our dataset. This approach required additional time and resources, but it was a more measured response than starting from scratch. The recalibration not only corrected the discrepancies but also improved the overall robustness of our data. As a result, we not only met our project milestones but also enhanced the credibility of our findings. This experience reinforced the value of methodical problem-solving and has honed my ability to navigate complex challenges by focusing on evidence and systematic evaluation.”

Top 20 Restaurant Management Interview Questions & Answers

Top 20 typography interview questions & answers, you may also be interested in..., top 20 telephonic interview questions & answers, top 20 statistical interview questions & answers, top 20 media relations interview questions & answers, top 20 physical education interview questions & answers.

DEI in 2024 is a more polarized topic than in 2020 – Check out our recent survey and get the insights Download the report

• HR Toolkit |
• HR Templates |
• Interview questions |

Critical-thinking interview questions and answers

Use these sample critical-thinking interview questions to discover how candidates evaluate complex situations and if they can reach logical decisions.

An experienced recruiter and HR professional who has transferred her expertise to insightful content to support others in HR.

10 good critical-thinking interview questions

• Tell me about a time you had to make a decision with incomplete information. What did you do?
• During a live presentation to key stakeholders, you spot a mistake in your manager’s report, but your manager isn’t at the presentation. How do you handle this?
• Describe a time when you had to convince your manager to try a different approach to solve a problem.
• You’re working on a project and you struggle coming to an agreement with your team about your next step. What would you do to make sure you choose the right direction and get your co-workers onboard?
• What’s the best sales approach: increase prices to achieve higher revenues or decrease prices to improve customer satisfaction?
• How do you evaluate the credibility of a source of information?
• Describe a situation where you had to adapt your communication style to effectively convey your message.
• How do you prioritize tasks when faced with multiple urgent deadlines?
• What steps do you take to analyze a complex problem?
• Can you give an example of a time when you had to think on your feet during a crisis?

Here are 10 essential interview questions and sample answers to help identify the best candidates for this role.

1. Tell me about a time you had to make a decision with incomplete information. What did you do?

This question assesses how the candidate makes decisions when they don’t have all the facts.

Sample answer:

“I once had to decide on a vendor with limited information. I prioritized the most critical factors like reliability and cost, and made a provisional choice, subject to change as more information became available.”

2. During a live presentation to key stakeholders, you spot a mistake in your manager’s report, but your manager isn’t at the presentation. How do you handle this?

This question evaluates the candidate’s ability to handle sensitive situations tactfully.

“I would subtly correct the mistake without drawing attention to it, and later discuss it privately with my manager to prevent future errors.”

3. Describe a time when you had to convince your manager to try a different approach to solve a problem.

This question gauges the candidate’s ability to influence others and advocate for better solutions.

“I suggested an alternative workflow to my manager that could save time. I presented data to back up my proposal, and after a trial period, my approach was adopted.”

4. You’re working on a project and you struggle coming to an agreement with your team about your next step. What would you do to make sure you choose the right direction and get your co-workers onboard?

This question assesses the candidate’s collaborative problem-solving skills.

“I would facilitate a team discussion to hear all perspectives. We would weigh the pros and cons of each option and come to a consensus, ensuring everyone feels heard.”

5. What’s the best sales approach: increase prices to achieve higher revenues or decrease prices to improve customer satisfaction?

This question tests the candidate’s ability to think critically about business strategies.

“Both approaches have merits and drawbacks. The best strategy would depend on the company’s goals, market conditions, and customer base.”

6. How do you evaluate the credibility of a source of information?

This question assesses the candidate’s ability to discern reliable information.

“I look at the source’s reputation, the quality of the content, and whether the information is supported by credible references.”

7. Describe a situation where you had to adapt your communication style to effectively convey your message.

This question evaluates the candidate’s flexibility in communication to suit different situations.

“When presenting technical information to non-technical stakeholders, I avoid jargon and use analogies to make the content more relatable.”

8. How do you prioritize tasks when faced with multiple urgent deadlines?

This question assesses the candidate’s time-management and decision-making skills.

“I categorize tasks based on their urgency and importance. I tackle high-priority tasks first and delegate when possible.”

9. What steps do you take to analyze a complex problem?

This question gauges the candidate’s problem-solving methodology.

“I break down the problem into smaller parts, analyze each component, identify root causes, and then develop a step-by-step solution.”

10. Can you give an example of a time when you had to think on your feet during a crisis?

This question tests the candidate’s ability to think critically under pressure.

“During a system outage, I quickly assessed the situation, communicated with the team, and implemented a contingency plan to minimize downtime.”

What does a good critical-thinking candidate look like?

A strong candidate with critical-thinking skills is analytical, adaptable, and able to make well-reasoned decisions. They should also be effective communicators who can collaborate to solve problems.

Why test candidates’ critical-thinking skills

Critical-thinking skills allow people to evaluate situations through reasoning to reach logical decisions. Companies benefit from employees who think critically (as opposed to mechanically performing tasks) because these individuals use an independent mindset to seek ways to improve processes.

Critical thinkers are great assets in all teams and roles. They are:

• Responsible. You can count on them to make tough decisions.
• Consistent. They’re top performers who check their facts before acting.
• Unbiased. They keep their emotions in check to reach sound decisions.
• Creative. They suggest out-of-the-box solutions.

Challenge candidates with complex critical thinking questions to reveal their skills. But, present them with realistic problems related to the job. Brainteasers (e.g. some Google-type questions) are off-putting for candidates who already feel the pressure of the interview process. Questions like “How many haircuts happen in America every year?” are very popular online, but may not reveal much about their skills. Asking something like “How would you explain cloud computing to a 6-year-old?” will more accurately show you a candidate’s way of thinking.

Keep your challenging interview questions as job-related as possible. Sometimes it’s not important to assess whether the answer is right or wrong. Puzzling questions are your opportunity to evaluate how candidates react outside their comfort zone.

These critical-thinking interview question examples will help you identify candidates with high potential for future leadership positions. Combine them with various behavioral interview question types (like problem-solving and competency-based questions) to create complete candidate profiles and make better hiring decisions.

How to assess critical-thinking skills in interviews

• Use hypothetical scenarios and examples from candidates’ past experiences to understand their mindsets. An analytical way of thinking (comparing alternatives and weighing pros and cons) indicates people who make logical judgments.
• When problems arise, employees don’t always have ample time to design a detailed action plan. Opt for candidates who strike a balance between good and fast decision-making.
• Critical thinking requires questioning facts and the status quo. Look for candidates who have implemented new procedures or applied changes to processes in their past positions. These are signs of professionals who actively seek ways to improve how things get done, as opposed to taking the “this is how we always do it” approach.
• Candidates who are intrigued by solving problems are more likely to effectively manage challenges and stressful situations on the job. During your interview process, keep an eye out for candidates who show enthusiasm and don’t easily quit when faced with problems, even if they can’t immediately find solutions.
• They don’t fact-check. If you present candidates with a hypothetical problem and they don’t ask for clarifications, it’s a sign they take information for granted. A critical thinker should always research data for accuracy before relying on it.
• They make assumptions. Beyond taking things for granted, employees who make assumptions tend to jump to rushed and often biased conclusions. Look for candidates who use logical arguments to justify their decisions.
• They don’t answer. If they don’t at least try to solve the problem, they’ll probably keep procrastinating when something goes wrong or push their work onto to someone else. Asking for help when you face a challenge is more than acceptable, but avoiding problems reveals irresponsible employee behavior.
• They give you the obvious answer. Tricky questions are tricky for a reason. Candidates who go with the first answer that comes in mind are more likely to approach challenges superficially and avoid using critical-thinking skills to come up with the best solution.

Frequently asked questions

Want a custom interview kit, related interview questions.

• Problem-solving interview questions and answers
• Analytical interview questions and answers
• Decision-making interview questions and answers

Related Topics

• How to assess soft skills in an interview
• A guide to interview preparation for employers
• How to interview candidates for better hiring results

Jump to section

Let's grow together.

Explore our full platform with a 15-day free trial. Post jobs, get candidates and onboard employees all in one place.

Share on Mastodon

Critical Thinking Interview Questions & Answers

• Updated July 13, 2023
• Published March 28, 2021

In dynamic and competitive work environments, it’s important that a business can keep up with innovations and changing demands from customers. This is why employers look for candidates who possess strong critical thinking skills and decision-making skills.

Interviewers use job interviews to assess your critical thinking skills. They do this by asking you questions that require you to demonstrate your ability to effectively and efficiently evaluate information to make a calculated decision. Your goal is to demonstrate that you are an innovative person that can provide rational advice and thought-out solutions when needed.

Critical thinking questions are commonly asked during job interviews because workers with strong critical thinking skills are important for companies to excel. Questions about your critical thinking skills are often  behavioral interview questions . These are a strategic type of interview questions that require you to provide an answer that includes an example situation that you experienced in your career and how you acted in that situation.

A basic example of a behavioral question in relation to critical thinking is ‘ describe a time you had to solve a problem at work without having all the information or resources .’ As you can see, the interviewer is looking for you to explain a situation where you had to think outside the box and justify your critical thinking process.

What Are Critical Thinking Interview Questions?

Critical thinking skills are related to your ability to analyze, evaluate and assess information effectively and make calculated decisions. Below we discuss a couple of important skills related to critical thinking. You must demonstrate that you possess these skills to convince the interviewer that you possess the right critical thinking skills to succeed in the position you’re applying for.

Examples of critical thinking skills are:

Observation & analysis.

The ability to observe and analyze a (potential) problem or data set is where a critical thinking process starts. People who possess strong analytical skills examine the information and understand what it means in order to explain the implications to others properly.

After a thoughtful observation and analysis, creative skills and innovation are required to spot patterns in the information or data. Critical thinkers are able to think outside the box to come up with a solution no one else thought of before. This requires flexibility, conceptualization, and imagination to take a different approach from other approaches.

• Communication

Critical thinkers also possess strong communication skills to share their approaches and conclusions with coworkers. It’s essential that ideas and solutions are shared effectively and efficiently with others. Furthermore, working together with others is an important part of the critical thinking process to figure out the right solution to business challenges. Skills involved are active listening, teamwork , collaboration, and interpersonal skills.

Problem-solving

Once an analysis is performed and solutions are discussed, it’s important that a solution is implemented. An essential part of critical thinking is coming up with an efficient solution and assessing the impact of this decision. This requires adaptability as well to modify the course of action as needed throughout the implementation process.

Critical Thinking Behavioral Interview Questions

Most questions interviewers will ask you about your critical thinking skills are  behavioral interview questions . These questions require you to provide specific examples of past work experiences in which you demonstrated your critical thinking skills. For interviewers, understanding your past professional behavior and performance is the best way to gauge your future job behavior and performance.

Behavioral questions are focused on the desired skills or competency area, such as, in this case, critical thinking. Other common competency areas for which behavioral questions are used are teamwork , communication , time management , creative thinking skills , leadership , adaptability , conflict resolution , etc.

Behavioral job interview questions usually start with:

• Give me an example of
• Tell me about a time when you
• What would you do
• Describe a situation where

Examples of critical thinking behavioral interview questions:

• Give me an example of a time you had to solve a problem without having complete information or resources.
• Tell me about a time when you presented a new idea or process to your team.
• What would you do if you had a deadline coming up, but you do not have all the components to deliver a project on time?
• Describe a situation where you find a creative way to overcome a business challenge.

As you can see, the questions mentioned above require you to discuss your past behavior. For interviewers, the most accurate predictor of future performance is your past performance in similar situations.

Before making a hiring decision, interviewers are interested in discussing previous work situations. The right interview preparation will help you do the right research to prepare answers that include the critical thinking skills the interviewer is looking for. This starts with  thoroughly reviewing the job description . The job description usually tells more about the specific skills that are required for the position. You can use this information to prepare answers that include times you were successfully using the skills the employer is looking for.

To answer behavioral questions successfully, you need to provide the interviewer with specific details about a time you used your critical thinking skills. Your answer should include the situation you were in, your task in that situation, the actions you took, and the specific results you got. In short, this is called the STAR method  of providing an answer. The STAR method is discussed in more detail later on in this article.

Why Interviewers Ask Critical Thinking Interview Questions

For interviewers, the most effective way to reveal your critical thinking skills is by asking you to describe past work experiences or provide you with hypothetical scenarios. The main reason for asking you about situations in which you successfully used your critical thinking skills is to get an understanding of how you think and act in specific, challenging situations.

Before hiring a candidate, employers want to determine if you are:

• Responsible enough to identify, analyze, and solve problems
• Able to solve a problem without having all the required data, information, or resources
• Creative enough to come up with out-of-the-box solutions
• A strong communicator who can explain issues and involve others in the problem-solving process
• Taking responsibility for your actions

During a job interview, it’s important that you have a few examples ready to discuss times you used your critical thinking skills in different situations. A proven track record of critical thinking to tackle challenges will help you convince the interviewer. This is also the reason why it’s smart to prepare answers related to the requirements for the position, prior to your job interview.

For example, if you work as a business analyst, you should be able to deal with business challenges such as changing requirements or business needs, which require critical thinking skills. Business analysts need to identify (possible) problems and are required to come up with solutions and strategies.

What Employers Look For In A Critical Thinking Interview

During a job interview, you must convince the interviewers of your critical thinking skills. Interviewers look for candidates whose work ethic and career goals align with the company culture and what they can offer you. This is also the reason why you should relate your answers to the job requirements and what the company is looking for.

The right interview preparation will help you get there. Your goal is to demonstrate that you are a strong critical thinker that is capable of taking on the day-to-day tasks required for the position and have the potential to grow .

Critical thinking interview questions are used to reveal how you identify and approach problems, if you can evaluate a point of view to determine if it’s valid or not, and if you can provide structured reasoning to support an argument. Basically, the interviewers want to get the following questions answered:

• How do you think challenges or issues through in an objective and critical way?
• Can you identify different points of view in relation to a particular problem?
• Are you able to evaluate different points of view to determine how valid or strong they are?
• Can you identify weak points that are in possible solutions or arguments?
• How do you provide structured reasoning and support for arguments when communicating with other people?

Red Flags In Critical Thinking Skills Job Interviews

There are several things you should avoid when answering critical thinking interview questions. Below we discuss a couple of red flags that could hurt your chances of landing the job you want. Make sure you avoid these mistakes during your interview to prevent a situation where you could give the interviewer the wrong impression.

1. No clear critical thinking process

The interviewer wants you to walk them through your critical thinking process. This means that you need to explain how you tackled an issue or problem by using your critical thinking skills.

A perfect answer includes a story in which you explain how you identified a problem, how you analyzed and evaluated the situation to figure out which data, facts, or information was important. Next, tell them how you made inferences and communicated issues and possible solutions with coworkers and other stakeholders. Finally, discuss how you executed the solution you came up with.

Not being able to give the interviewer a clear example in which you walk them through the steps mentioned above could be a warning sign for them. Therefore, make sure that you have a strong answer ready that relates to the job requirements and includes you successfully using your critical thinking skills to your advantage.

2. Not providing enough critical details

When interviewers ask you about your critical thinking skills, and if you can walk them through a specific time you successfully used those skills, it’s important that you include every step of your critical reasoning process.

If you claim to be a strong critical thinker that can take on the responsibilities of the position you’re applying for, you need to make sure you can back this up through clear examples of times you used these skills. Failing to do so could lead to the elimination of your chances to land the job. If the interviewer has trouble verifying your employment history, this is considered a warning sign.

3. Not taking responsibility

Taking responsibility is an important characteristic of a critical thinker. If a problem is identified but not addressed, this could quickly escalate into a bigger problem. If your answers indicate that you do not take responsibility or if you have left things for later, this could leave the impression on the interviews that your critical thinking skills and work engagement is not top-notch. Therefore, make sure you demonstrate that you take responsibility for your actions and that you’re a proactive worker that immediately deals with challenges as soon as they occur or when they are identified as potential problems.

To test you during your job interview, interviewers will ask you about times you failed in specific work situations . This is especially the case for positions where you deal with challenging situations and are required to deal with identifying and solve problems. Interviewers are interested in what went wrong in specific work situations, if you took responsibility for your actions, and what you learned from that situation. Not taking responsibility for, for instance, a  project that may have failed , is considered a warning sign for employers.

Self-awareness and being to reflect on situations that went wrong is an important characteristic to possess in the workplace – especially in work environments where critical thinking skills are important. Employers want to hire a candidate who can admit errors or who made thoughtful mistakes trying to solve problems in the past and learned from them. Employers know that candidates are human and make mistakes, just like everybody else. It’s important that your answers demonstrate that you take responsibility for situations and describe the actions you took to repair any problems or challenges.

Common Critical Thinking Interview Questions

Below we discuss common  behavioral critical thinking interview questions . These questions are broken down into two categories; regular behavioral interview questions and hypothetical interview questions.

Learn everything you need to know about commonly asked interview questions that are frequently asked during job interviews .

Behavioral Critical Thinking Interview Questions:

• Tell me about a time you had to make a decision without having all the data, information, or resources.
• Give me an example of a time you discovered a mistake that
• What do you consider the most difficult decision you had to make at work? What results did you get?
• Describe a time you convince a colleague or supervisor to use an alternative approach to solve a problem.
• Give me an example of a time you were involved in solving a problem among team members on how to approach a project.
• Tell me about a time you came up with a new or unusual idea to deal with a challenge.
• Describe a time you anticipated a potential problem. How did you develop preventative measures?
• Give me an example of a time when you faced an unexpected challenge at work and how you dealt with it.
• Describe a time a customer approached you with a problem or concern. How did you respond?
• Give me an example of a time you had to change your planned course of action at the last moment. How did you re-evaluate your priorities?
• What do you consider your most innovative new idea that you have implemented in the workplace?
• Have you ever improved the workflow of a project based on your analysis? How did you do this?
• When you’re working on several projects, it’s tricky to deliver excellent service to all of them. How do you go about prioritizing the needs of a client?

Situational Critical Thinking Interview Questions:

• How would you go about convincing a coworker, manager, or other stakeholders to try an alternative approach to solve a problem?
• What would you do if you had a deadline coming up, but you did not yet have all the required information to deliver a project on time?
• How would you determine if you need help from others when you’re solving a problem or completing a task?
• If an order has been delayed and an angry client contacts you to cancel the order and close their account, what actions would you take?
• How would you deal with a situation where you identify a weak link in a process that’s impacting quality?
• What would be your approach if you and a colleague or teammates disagree on how to move forward on a project?

How To Answer Critical Interview Questions

Interviewers look for candidates who can demonstrate through examples that they use reason and logic to make decisions. In order to do this, it’s essential that you structure your answers in such a way that you walk the interviewer through an example situation in which you successfully used your critical thinking skills. To get started, you can consider the following steps.

Step 1: Research.

Every interview preparation starts with doing the right research. Before you can answer interview questions in a specific way you need to get to know the position and company better. Furthermore, you should thoroughly understand the job requirements to prepare strong answers.

Read the job description carefully to find specific skills that a candidate needs to possess to perform the job successfully. Think of skills such as creative thinking ,  problem-solving ,  adaptability , a strong work ethic , and  communication . Also, read the company website to get more information about their mission statement and who their main clients are. Furthermore, check their LinkedIn pages and other content/news related to the company.

Researching the job and company will help you identify the required skills, qualities, and work experience for the position you’re applying for. Your research should help you make an educated guess about what kind of interview questions you can expect .

Step 2: Write down the required job skills & competencies.

Behavioral interview questions about critical thinking skills are a perfect opportunity for you to demonstrate why you are the right candidate for the position.

The skills and competencies  you have identified in your research should be your starting point to prepare answers. Write down the required skills and rank them on importance.

Step 3: Create a list of past work experiences that relate to the required job skills.

Once you have ranked the skills on importance, you can start thinking of work experiences related to these skills. Coming up with a specific answer when you’re being put on the spot during an interview is very hard, especially when discussing critical thinking skills.

Interviewers want to hear how you evaluate and assess information objectively and how you make calculated decisions. Therefore, ensure that you come up with strong examples to questions you expect ahead of your interview. Create a list of past work experiences and tailor them to the required critical thinking skills. Highlight situations where you successfully provided rational advice, came up with thought-out solutions, and made fair assessments in your work. Focus on delivering a concise and to-the-point answer.

Step 4: Prepare successful and challenging answer examples.

Strong critical thinkers are essential in the workplace. Critical thinkers use their skills to evaluate and assess information in order to make decisions effectively. During your interview, it’s therefore important that your answers demonstrate that you have successfully identified problems, proposed solutions, evaluated several options, and finally implemented a solution.

It’s also likely that the interviewer will ask you about a time you have failed to solve a problem . Interviewers ask you about failures to assess whether or not you learn from your mistakes and if you’re self-aware enough to acknowledge times you failed. Also, it helps them identify if you take calculated and smart risks when it comes to making decisions.

Step 5: Use the STAR method to structure your answers

The STAR method allows you to concisely provide the interviewer an answer by logically walking them through the situation. STAR is an acronym that stands for a situation ( S ), your task ( T ) in that situation, the actions ( A ) you took, and what results ( R ) you got based on your actions. These are the basic steps you take in your walkthrough.

Below we discuss the STAR interview technique in more detail.

STAR Interview Technique

By using the STAR method, you can give an answer that includes exactly what the interviewer is looking for. Below, the STAR acronym is broken down into each step.

Start your answer by explaining the situation that you faced. The start of your answer ‘story’ should answer questions such as:

• What was the situation/problem?
• Who was involved?
• Why did the situation happen at that time?

It’s important to provide context around what problem needed to be solved. Furthermore, make sure to provide relevant details of why you had to use your critical thinking skills in that particular situation.

Next, explain your specific role in the task ahead. Include important details, such as specific responsibilities. Focus on giving the interviewer an understanding of your task in solving the problem. This part of your answer should answer questions such as:

• Why were you involved in that specific situation?
• What’s the background story?

After you describe your task, it’s time to specifically discuss the actions you took to solve the problem. Give the interviewer a detailed description of the actions you took. This part of your answer should answer questions such as:

• What steps did you take to resolve the situation you were in?
• Why did you choose to complete your tasks this way?

Finish your answer by discussing the results you got from your actions. Detail the outcomes of your actions and ensure to highlight your strengths . Also, make sure to take credit for your behavior that led to the result. Focus on positive results and positive learning experiences. This part of your answer ‘story’ should answer questions such as:

• What exactly happened?
• What did you accomplish?
• How did you feel about the results you got?
• What did you learn from the situation?
• How did this particular situation influence who you are as a professional today?

Sample Answers to Critical Thinking Questions

Below you will find some example questions. The examples are already written in STAR format so that you can clearly see how you can structure your answers when answering critical thinking interview questions.

However, these are ‘general’ examples. Do not forget to structure your own answers in a way that includes enough detail to convince the interviewer that you’re the right person for the job! This means that you need to tailor your answer to the specific skills required for the position you’re applying for.

Critical Thinking Question 1 : ‘Tell Me About a Time You Had To Solve a Challenging Problem At Work.’

‘In my position as a business development manager at ABC Software, I’m responsible for organizing all client events and conferences. ABC Software is a major player in the IT market, and during our events, we invite industry experts to speak on market developments. These events are used to attract new clients but also to maintain our relationship with our existing ones.

Over the last two years, we analyzed our attendee data and found out that our event attendance dropped almost 10%. Furthermore, we discovered that the retention rate of our clients also decreased. When we had to plan the next event, my team and I knew that we have to get our attendance levels back up for the events to stay successful. The goal was to get our networking event popular and recurring again.

I had an idea why the attendance levels dropped, but to get more information, I interviewed several sales consultants as well. The main feedback was that we should focus more on attracting new clients through social media channels. I communicated this with our marketing team, and we decided to also reach out to our client base and ask them what they would like to see on our future events. This led to interesting new insights on topics and speakers that we could invite, plus we also received input on how to improve networking possibilities during our events. Based on our research and feedback, I created a new plan of action to market our events through our social media channels to increase exposure.

After launching our marketing campaign, we immediately gained traction online, which led to an increase in advance registrations. For that specific event, we saw a total increase in attendance of 20% in comparison to the previous year. An online survey showed that the attendees were happy with how the way the new event was structured, and 80% of respondents said that it would be likely that they would recommend our events within their network.

My approach to increase attendance at our events did not go unnoticed. My department director asked me to make a presentation about how I tackled this problem and present this to the board.’

Why this is a strong critical thinking answer:

• This example shows that you’re able to identify issues and that you understand your responsibility to address them.
• The provided example is related but also relevant to the workplace. It’s also concise, which is perfect.
• This answer shows important skills, such as being proactive, teamwork , adaptability , problem-solving skills , and creativity .
• Taking responsibility to find out why the event attendance dropped and subsequently taking action turned out successful, which gives more weight to the situation.

Critical Thinking Question 2: ‘ Tell Me About a Time You Had To Make a Decision Without Complete Information.’

Situation & task.

‘In my current positions as a market research analyst, I have dealt with several situations where I had to make a decision without complete information. Even though it’s important to have all relevant and complete information, in this position, this just isn’t possible at times.

A recent example is when I had to make a sales prediction of a new innovative product feature we were about to launch. However, the product was new in the market in our area, which made it challenging to assess the expected market conditions to make an accurate forecast. 

In a situation where I do not have complete information, I start with analyzing the information that I do have and start working from there.   In this case, I researched information, documentation, and sales results of comparable markets outside of our region for comparison purposes. Furthermore, I called in expert advice of specialists of these comparable markets to get more accurate market knowledge. 

Based on the available information, additional research of comparable markets, and conversations with the experts, I developed a new spreadsheet with more adjustable parameters than normal because there were more uncertainties. Also,  I broke the sales forecast down into monthly, quarterly, half-annually, and annual figures. Breaking the forecast down into smaller timelines made it easier to make adjustments based on actual sales to make the calculations more accurate over time. 

I initiated a brainstorming session with my team leader to discuss my research findings and spreadsheet proposal. I value different points of view, especially from colleagues with more work experience that have dealt with these circumstances before . Based on the feedback I got, I made final adjustments to the report before turning it in.

Even though I did not have all the information required to make a solid prediction like I wanted to, it allowed me to provide my manager with a report with as few assumptions as possible. The product feature launch was a success, and the forecast turned out to be accurate within the set range. My manager asked me to make a presentation about how I approached this situation and explain the new forecast model to my colleagues.’ 

Why this is a strong answer:

• The provided example is to the point and demonstrates critical thinking skills.
• This answer shows other important skills such as problem-solving skills  and  adaptability .
• The answer shows that you’re a team player and that you involve others for the better of a project’s result.

Note : This is a basic example of how to structure a critical thinking answer. However, there’s a chance the interviewer wants you to go into more detail about which specific steps you took to deal with the situation of not having complete information.

Critical Thinking Question 3: ‘ Tell me about a time you convinced a coworker to implement a different process for better results.’

‘Personally, I believe that communication is essential in such a situation to find a way that works best for the company but also best for both of us. Finding a compromise is the main goal to get the work done to the best of our ability.

Task & Action

As a management consultant, I encountered a situation where I had to convince a coworker to implement a different process. A colleague disagreed with the way I wanted to handle an issue that we encountered along the way. To address this issue, I scheduled a meeting with him to discuss the situation. I asked him about his points of view and how he thought we should go about the project.

Even though we had differences in how we felt like how the project should be approached, we quickly concluded that our goal was the same; providing our client with a high-quality final product within the set deadline.

We talked about the project and the specific aspect about which we had a difference. I explained my point of view and that I had already encountered a similar issue in the past. Ultimately, my colleague agreed to tackle the issue in the method I proposed. His insights gave me a good suggestion which we incorporated into the project as well. After that, we successfully worked together and finalized the project in time, and according to the quality level we both were proud of.’

• The provided example is concise and relevant to the workplace where problem-solving skills are important.
• This answer shows important skills such as being proactive, problem-solving skills , persuasion skills, and adaptability .
• The answer shows that you’re a team player and that you listen to the input of others for the better of a project’s result.

Note : There’s always a chance that interviewers ask you follow-up questions about how you convinced your colleague. Make sure that you can answer those questions as well.

Rate this article

Your page rank:

Interview categories

• Interview Questions
• Cover Letter
• Interview Tips

Megainterview/Contact

• Career Interview Questions
• Write For Megainterview!
• Editorial Policy
• Privacy Policy / GDPR
• Terms & Conditions
• Contact: [email protected]

Sign-up for our newsletter

🤝 We’ll never spam you or sell your data

Popular Topics

• Accomplishments
• Adaptability
• Career Change
• Career Goals
• Conflict Resolution
• Creative Thinking
• Critical Thinking
• Cultural Fit
• Customer Service
• Entry-Level & No Experience
• Growth Potential
• Honesty & Integrity
• Job Satisfaction
• Negotiation Skills
• Performance Based
• Phone Interview
• Problem-Solving
• Questions to Ask the Interviewer
• Salary & Benefits
• Situational & Scenario-Based
• Stress Management
• Time Management & Prioritization
• Uncomfortable
• Work Experience

Popular Articles

• What Is The Most Challenging Project You Have Worked On?
• Tell Me About a Time You Had to Deal With a Difficult Customer
• What Have You Done To Improve Yourself In The Past Year?
• Interview Question: How Do You Deal With Tight Deadlines?
• Describe a Time You Demonstrated Leadership
• Tell Me About a Time When You Took Action to Resolve a Problem
• Job Interview Questions About Working in Fast-Paced Environments
• Job Interview: What Areas Need Improvement? (+ Answers)
• Tell Me About a Time You Were On a Team Project That Failed
• Tell Me About a Time You Managed an Important Project

Our mission is to

Help you get hired.

Hofplein 20

3032 AC, Rotterdam, the Netherlands

Turn interviews into offers

Every other Tuesday, get our Chief Coach’s best job-seeking and interviewing tips to land your dream job. 5-minute read.

Top 50 Critical Thinking Interview Questions and Answers

Streamline hiring with effortless screening tools

Optimise your hiring process with HiPeople's AI assessments and reference checks.

In this article

In today's competitive job market, employers are increasingly seeking candidates with strong critical thinking skills. Whether you're a recent graduate or a seasoned professional, mastering these skills can significantly enhance your chances of acing your next job interview.

In this guide, we'll walk you through everything you need to know about critical thinking interviews, from understanding their importance to providing sample answers and effective strategies. Let's dive in and equip you with the tools to succeed!

The Fundamentals of Critical Thinking

Before we delve into specific interview questions, it's essential to grasp the fundamental concepts of critical thinking. Critical thinking refers to the ability to analyze, evaluate, and synthesize information objectively, leading to well-informed decisions and problem-solving. It involves a combination of analytical, creative, and logical thinking skills, enabling individuals to navigate complex situations efficiently.

To develop your critical thinking abilities, you must understand the key components of this cognitive process. These components include:

• Analysis : Breaking down complex information into its constituent parts to comprehend the underlying structure and relationships.
• Evaluation : Assessing the strengths and weaknesses of different arguments, ideas, or solutions based on evidence and logic.
• Inference : Drawing logical conclusions and implications from available information and evidence.
• Explanation : Clearly communicating your thought processes, reasoning, and conclusions to others.
• Problem-Solving : Identifying and defining problems, exploring potential solutions, and choosing the most appropriate course of action.
• Creativity : Thinking outside the box to generate innovative ideas and approaches to challenges.

How to Prepare for Critical Thinking Interviews?

As with any interview, preparation is crucial for success. When it comes to critical thinking interviews, adequate preparation allows you to showcase your abilities confidently. Follow these steps to get ready for your interview:

• Research the Company and Industry : Understand the company's mission, values, and recent developments. Familiarize yourself with the industry's trends and challenges.
• Review the Job Description and Requirements : Analyze the job description to identify the critical thinking skills the employer seeks. Tailor your answers to align with these expectations.
• Understand the Common Critical Thinking Skills Employers Seek : Employers often look for skills such as analytical thinking, problem-solving, creativity, and decision-making. Be prepared to demonstrate these skills in your answers.
• Assess Your Own Critical Thinking Abilities and Weaknesses : Reflect on your past experiences and identify situations where you applied critical thinking effectively. Recognize areas for improvement and be ready to discuss your efforts to develop those skills.

Types of Critical Thinking Interview Questions

Critical thinking interview questions can be grouped into several categories. Each category assesses different aspects of your cognitive abilities . Let's explore each type:

Situational Questions

Situational questions present hypothetical scenarios to assess how you would handle specific situations in the workplace. The employer is interested in your problem-solving approach and decision-making process. Examples of situational questions include:

• Scenario 1: Dealing with a Team Member's Incompetence How would you handle a team member who consistently fails to meet deadlines or deliver satisfactory work? ‍
• Scenario 2: Handling a Tight Project Deadline You're assigned a high-priority project with an extremely tight deadline. How do you prioritize tasks and ensure timely completion?

Behavioral Questions

Behavioral questions inquire about your past experiences and actions to predict your future behavior. The employer seeks examples of how you approached challenges in the past. Examples of behavioral questions include:

• Question 1: Describe a Time You Resolved a Complex Problem Share a specific example of a complex problem you faced at work. How did you approach the situation, and what was the outcome? ‍
• Question 2: How Did You Handle a Conflict with a Coworker? Discuss a time when you had a disagreement with a coworker. How did you manage the situation to reach a resolution?

Hypothetical Questions

Hypothetical questions gauge your ability to think on your feet and assess how you approach novel situations. Employers are interested in your thought process and ability to generate solutions under pressure. Examples of hypothetical questions include:

• Question 1: What Would You Do If You Had to Meet a Challenging Sales Target? Imagine you're responsible for meeting a challenging sales target in a short period. How would you strategize and approach the task? ‍
• Question 2: Imagine a New Product Idea for Our Company. If given the opportunity to propose a new product idea for the company, what would it be, and how would you present its potential value?

Puzzle and Brain Teaser Questions

Puzzle and brain teaser questions test your ability to think critically, logically, and creatively. They often involve solving mathematical or logic problems or answering riddles. Examples of puzzle and brain teaser questions include:

• Question 1: How Many Golf Balls Can You Fit in a School Bus? Estimate the number of golf balls that can fit in a standard school bus. Explain your reasoning. ‍
• Question 2: How Do You Arrange Six Books on a Shelf with Limited Space? Arrange six books of different sizes on a narrow shelf with limited space. Describe your arrangement strategy.

Critical Thinking Skills and How to Develop Them

To excel in critical thinking interviews, you must cultivate specific skills that are highly valued by employers. Let's explore each critical thinking skill and strategies to develop them:

Analytical Thinking

Analytical thinking involves breaking complex problems into smaller components to understand their underlying structure and relationships. To enhance analytical thinking:

• Improve Data Interpretation and Evaluation: Practice analyzing data and information from different sources, such as reports, graphs, or case studies. Use this data to draw meaningful insights and conclusions.
• Develop Logical Reasoning: Engage in activities that require logical thinking, such as puzzles, Sudoku, or logic games. This helps sharpen your ability to reason deductively and spot patterns.

Creative Thinking

Creative thinking allows you to generate innovative ideas and solutions to challenges. To foster creativity:

• Cultivate Innovation and Idea Generation: Engage in brainstorming sessions with colleagues or friends. Encourage yourself to think beyond conventional solutions and explore new possibilities.
• Overcome Mental Blocks and Bias: Be aware of your cognitive biases and actively challenge them. Adopt a growth mindset that embraces new perspectives and encourages experimentation.

Problem-Solving

Problem-solving is the process of identifying issues and finding effective solutions to address them. To refine your problem-solving skills:

• Identify Root Causes: When facing a problem, dig deep to identify its underlying causes. Avoid addressing symptoms only.
• Apply Effective Solutions: Evaluate different potential solutions and their implications before implementing the most appropriate one.

Decision-Making

Decision-making involves making choices based on logical analysis and consideration of available information. To improve decision-making:

• Weigh Pros and Cons: Make a list of the advantages and disadvantages of each option before reaching a decision.
• Make Informed and Rational Choices: Base your decisions on evidence and facts rather than emotions or personal biases.

The STAR Method: Structured Approach to Responding

During critical thinking interviews, using the STAR method can help you deliver structured and impactful answers. The STAR method involves:

• Situation : Describe the context and situation you encountered.
• Task : Explain the task or problem you faced.
• Action : Outline the actions you took to address the situation.
• Result : Describe the outcome of your actions and any lessons learned.

Situational Interview Questions

Question 1: "imagine you are leading a project, and a team member consistently misses deadlines and fails to deliver satisfactory work. how would you address this situation".

How to Answer : When responding to this question, emphasize your problem-solving and leadership skills. Describe how you would approach the team member privately to understand any challenges they may be facing. Focus on finding solutions collaboratively, setting clear performance expectations, and offering support or training if needed. Highlight the importance of regular check-ins to monitor progress and provide constructive feedback.

Sample Answer : "If faced with a team member consistently missing deadlines, I would take a proactive approach. I would schedule a one-on-one meeting to understand the root cause of the issue and offer my support in finding solutions. By setting clear expectations and providing additional resources, I believe we can overcome this challenge together. Regular check-ins will help us track progress, and I am confident that with constructive feedback, the team member can improve their performance."

What to Look For : Hiring managers should focus on candidates who demonstrate strong communication skills, empathy, and a collaborative approach to problem-solving. Look for candidates who prioritize finding solutions and are willing to offer support to their team members.

Question 2: "You are responsible for managing a high-priority project with an extremely tight deadline. How would you prioritize tasks and ensure timely completion?"

How to Answer : Candidates should describe their process for breaking down the project into manageable tasks. Look for their ability to prioritize tasks based on urgency and dependencies. A strong response will demonstrate effective time management and the ability to communicate with stakeholders throughout the process.

Sample Answer : "To manage a high-priority project with a tight deadline, I would first break down the project into smaller tasks and identify critical milestones. By prioritizing tasks based on their dependencies and urgency, I can ensure that the most critical components are addressed first. Throughout the process, I would maintain open communication with the team and stakeholders, providing regular updates on progress and potential challenges."

What to Look For : Look for candidates who demonstrate excellent organizational and time management skills. Effective communication and the ability to handle pressure are also essential qualities to seek in their responses.

Behavioral Interview Questions

Question 3: "describe a time when you faced a complex problem at work. how did you approach the situation, and what was the outcome".

How to Answer : Candidates should provide a detailed account of the complex problem they encountered, the actions they took to resolve it, and the final outcome. Look for their ability to analyze the situation critically, make informed decisions, and adapt their approach as needed.

Sample Answer : "In my previous role, we faced a significant production delay that was affecting the project timeline. To address the issue, I gathered information from various stakeholders to understand the root cause. Working with a cross-functional team, we brainstormed potential solutions and implemented a process improvement strategy. As a result, we successfully reduced production time by 20% and completed the project ahead of schedule."

What to Look For : Seek candidates who demonstrate problem-solving skills, adaptability, and the ability to work collaboratively with others to reach a positive outcome.

Question 4: " Tell me about a time when you had a disagreement with a coworker. How did you manage the situation to reach a resolution?"

How to Answer : Look for candidates who handle conflicts constructively. They should describe their approach to resolving the disagreement, actively listening to their coworker's perspective, finding common ground, and working collaboratively to reach a resolution.

Sample Answer : "In one instance, I had a disagreement with a coworker over the approach to a marketing campaign. I approached the situation by initiating a private conversation to understand their perspective fully. By actively listening to their concerns and sharing my viewpoint without becoming defensive, we identified areas of agreement and crafted a comprehensive marketing strategy that incorporated elements from both approaches."

What to Look For : Observe candidates' communication and interpersonal skills, as well as their ability to work effectively with colleagues and find solutions in challenging situations.

Hypothetical Interview Questions

Question 5: "imagine you are responsible for meeting a challenging sales target in a short period. how would you strategize and approach the task".

How to Answer : Candidates should demonstrate their ability to strategize and set achievable goals. They should discuss how they would analyze the market, collaborate with the sales team, and monitor progress to adapt their approach as necessary.

Sample Answer : "If faced with a challenging sales target, I would conduct a thorough market analysis to identify opportunities and target segments. Collaborating with the sales team, we would set realistic goals aligned with the target. Regular performance evaluations and team meetings would allow us to track progress and adjust strategies based on real-time data."

What to Look For : Look for candidates who show a strategic mindset, data-driven decision-making, and the ability to work effectively with teams to achieve goals.

Question 6: "If given the opportunity to propose a new product idea for the company, what would it be, and how would you present its potential value?"

How to Answer : Look for candidates who demonstrate creativity and innovation in their response. They should articulate a well-thought-out product idea and explain its potential value to the company and its customers.

Sample Answer : "I believe a mobile app that complements our existing software could be a game-changer. This app would provide users with on-the-go access to essential features, enabling them to work seamlessly even outside the office. The app's integration with popular third-party tools would enhance its appeal, creating a new revenue stream while strengthening customer loyalty."

What to Look For : Seek candidates who display creative thinking, market awareness, and a customer-centric mindset in their proposed product idea.

Puzzle and Brain Teaser Interview Questions

Question 7: "estimate the number of golf balls that can fit in a standard school bus. explain your reasoning.".

How to Answer : Candidates should approach this question logically, breaking down the problem into manageable steps. Look for their ability to estimate the volume of the school bus and the volume of a golf ball, and then perform the necessary calculations to arrive at an approximate answer.

Sample Answer : "To estimate the number of golf balls that can fit in a school bus, I would first calculate the volume of the bus by multiplying its length, width, and height. Then, I would determine the volume of a golf ball using its diameter. By dividing the bus's volume by the golf ball's volume, I can arrive at an approximate number."

What to Look For : Look for candidates who demonstrate analytical thinking, mathematical reasoning, and the ability to approach complex problems systematically.

Question 8: "How do you arrange six books of different sizes on a narrow shelf with limited space?"

How to Answer : Candidates should describe their strategy for efficiently utilizing the limited space on the shelf. Look for their ability to think creatively and find practical solutions to organizing the books.

Sample Answer : "To make the best use of the limited space, I would arrange the three large books horizontally at the bottom of the shelf. This arrangement optimizes the available width. For the three smaller books, I would arrange them vertically, either next to one another or slightly overlapped. This approach maximizes the use of the available vertical space without wasting any surface area."

What to Look For : Observe candidates' creative thinking and practical problem-solving skills when arranging the books on the narrow shelf.

Analytical Thinking Interview Questions

Question 9: "you have access to a large dataset containing customer information. how would you analyze this data to identify trends and insights".

How to Answer : Candidates should outline their analytical approach to handling the dataset. Look for their ability to use data analysis tools, interpret trends, and draw meaningful insights from the information.

Sample Answer : "To analyze the customer dataset, I would start by cleaning and organizing the data to ensure its accuracy. Then, I would use data visualization tools to identify patterns and trends. By segmenting the data based on key variables, I can gain insights into customer behaviors and preferences. Finally, I would interpret the findings and present actionable recommendations to the team."

What to Look For : Observe candidates' proficiency in data analysis, data visualization, and their ability to derive actionable insights from complex datasets.

Question 10: "You need to make a critical business decision with limited information. How do you approach this situation?"

How to Answer : Candidates should describe their decision-making process when faced with limited information. Look for their ability to gather relevant data, weigh pros and cons, and make informed decisions based on available evidence.

Sample Answer : "When making a critical business decision with limited information, I would first identify the most important factors influencing the decision. Then, I would gather as much relevant data as possible and consult with subject matter experts to fill in the gaps. By analyzing the available information and potential outcomes, I can make the best decision possible given the circumstances."

What to Look For : Seek candidates who demonstrate sound judgment, analytical thinking, and the ability to make well-reasoned decisions in ambiguous situations.

Decision-Making Interview Questions

Question 11: "you are part of a team tasked with selecting a vendor for a significant project. how would you approach the vendor selection process".

How to Answer : Candidates should outline their approach to vendor selection, including criteria, evaluation methods, and stakeholder involvement. Look for their ability to consider various factors and make a well-informed choice.

Sample Answer : "To approach the vendor selection process, I would collaborate with the team to define our specific needs and requirements. We would establish evaluation criteria, including cost, quality, experience, and reputation. After researching potential vendors and obtaining proposals, we would conduct interviews and assess their fit with our project. Involving key stakeholders in the decision-making process would ensure buy-in and support for the selected vendor."

What to Look For : Look for candidates who demonstrate a systematic approach to decision-making, stakeholder engagement, and the ability to consider multiple perspectives.

Question 12: "Imagine you are presented with two potential business strategies. Both have their advantages and disadvantages. How do you determine which strategy is the most viable?"

How to Answer : Candidates should describe their approach to evaluating the two strategies objectively. Look for their ability to weigh the pros and cons, assess potential risks, and align the strategies with the organization's goals.

Sample Answer : "When faced with two potential business strategies, I would conduct a comprehensive analysis of each option. This would involve evaluating the short-term and long-term benefits, potential risks, resource requirements, and alignment with our company's mission and vision. By consulting with key stakeholders and considering market trends, I can determine which strategy is the most viable for our organization's success."

What to Look For : Seek candidates who demonstrate critical thinking, strategic reasoning, and the ability to align decisions with the overall organizational objectives.

Creative Thinking Interview Questions

Question 13: "how do you foster a culture of innovation within a team or organization".

How to Answer : Candidates should discuss strategies for encouraging creativity and innovation among team members. Look for their ability to promote an open and collaborative environment that values new ideas.

Sample Answer : "To foster a culture of innovation, I would encourage open communication and idea-sharing among team members. Providing dedicated time for brainstorming sessions and acknowledging and rewarding innovative contributions can motivate team members to think creatively. Additionally, creating cross-functional teams and encouraging experimentation can lead to breakthrough solutions and new opportunities for the organization."

What to Look For : Observe candidates' ability to inspire creativity, promote collaboration, and create an environment that supports and rewards innovative thinking.

Question 14: "Share an example of a time when you implemented a creative solution to a challenging problem. How did your innovation make a positive impact?"

How to Answer : Candidates should describe a specific situation where they applied creative thinking to solve a problem. Look for their ability to articulate the problem-solving process and the positive outcomes of their innovation.

Sample Answer : "In a previous role, we were facing declining customer engagement with our website. To address this, I proposed a gamification strategy, incorporating interactive elements and rewards. By integrating quizzes and challenges, we increased user engagement significantly. This creative solution not only enhanced the user experience but also contributed to a 30% increase in website traffic and a 20% rise in customer retention."

What to Look For : Seek candidates who demonstrate a track record of creative problem-solving and their ability to implement innovative solutions with tangible positive outcomes.

Communication and Collaboration Interview Questions

Question 15: "you are part of a cross-functional team working on a complex project. how do you ensure effective communication and collaboration among team members".

How to Answer : Candidates should describe their approach to fostering effective communication and collaboration within a cross-functional team. Look for their ability to facilitate open dialogue, establish clear channels of communication, and promote a culture of teamwork.

Sample Answer : "To ensure effective communication and collaboration in a cross-functional team, I would start by establishing regular team meetings to discuss progress, challenges, and goals. By encouraging open and respectful communication, team members can share their perspectives and expertise freely. Additionally, I would utilize collaboration tools and project management software to centralize information and keep everyone informed. Recognizing and celebrating team achievements would also foster a positive and collaborative atmosphere."

What to Look For : Observe candidates' communication skills, team-building abilities, and their commitment to creating a cohesive and collaborative team environment.

These communication and collaboration questions are vital in assessing candidates ' ability to work effectively with others and contribute to a positive team dynamic. By incorporating questions that touch on various critical thinking skills, you can identify well-rounded candidates who will excel in your organization.

Unlock the Full List of Top 50 Interview Questions!

Looking to ace your next job interview? We've got you covered! Download our free PDF with the top 50 interview questions to prepare comprehensively and confidently. These questions are curated by industry experts to give you the edge you need.

Don't miss out on this opportunity to boost your interview skills. Get your free copy now!

How to Answer Critical Thinking Questions?

While answering critical thinking questions, it's crucial to convey your thoughts clearly and demonstrate your problem-solving skills effectively. Here are some strategies to keep in mind:

• Demonstrate Clear and Logical Thought Processes : Clearly outline the steps you took to analyze the situation, make decisions, and arrive at your conclusions.
• Use Specific Examples and Relevant Experiences : Draw from past experiences to provide concrete evidence of your critical thinking abilities.
• Emphasize Collaborative and Innovative Approaches : Highlight instances where you collaborated with others and embraced innovative solutions to demonstrate versatility.
• Handling Stress and Pressure During Critical Thinking Interviews : When answering complex questions, stay composed and focused. Take a moment to gather your thoughts before responding.

Mistakes to Avoid During Critical Thinking Interviews

To make the best impression during your critical thinking interview, avoid the following common pitfalls:

• Relying Solely on Intuition : While intuition can be valuable, support your answers with logical reasoning and evidence.
• Making Assumptions Without Proper Evidence : Base your responses on relevant information rather than assumptions.
• Avoiding Ambiguity and Vagueness in Responses : Be precise and concise in your answers to showcase your clarity of thought.
• Overlooking the Importance of Active Listening : Fully understand the question before responding to ensure you address the interviewer's query accurately.

Final Preparation Tips

As your critical thinking interview approaches, consider these final tips to boost your confidence:

• Maintain a Positive and Confident Attitude : Display enthusiasm and confidence in your abilities throughout the interview.
• Review Key Concepts and Skills : Revisit the critical thinking skills and strategies discussed in this guide to reinforce your understanding.
• Get Adequate Rest Before the Interview Day : Ensure you are well-rested to be mentally sharp and focused during the interview.

By understanding the fundamentals of critical thinking, preparing thoroughly, and practicing your responses, you are well-equipped to tackle any critical thinking question that comes your way. Remember to embrace the STAR method, provide specific examples, and maintain a composed demeanor during the interview. With these valuable tips and strategies, you are ready to impress prospective employers and secure your dream job. Best of luck in your interviews, and may your critical thinking skills shine brightly!

Free resources

Top 15 Pre-Employment Testing Hacks For Recruiters

Unlock the secrets to streamlined hiring with expert strategies to ace pre-employment testing, identify top talent, and make informed recruiting decisions!

How to Find Candidates With Strong Attention to Detail?

Unlock the secrets to discovering top talent who excel in precision and thoroughness, ensuring you have a team of individuals dedicated to excellence!

How to Reduce Time to Hire: 15 Effective Ways

Unlock the secrets to streamlining your recruitment process. Discover proven strategies to slash your time to hire and secure top talent efficiently!

How to Create a Bias-Free Hiring Process?

Unlock the key to fostering an inclusive workplace. Discover expert insights & strategies to craft a hiring process that champions diversity and eliminates bias!

Hiring Compliance: A Step-by-Step Guide for HR Teams

Navigate the intricate landscape of hiring regulations effortlessly, ensuring your recruitment processes adhere to legal standards and streamline your hiring!

Data-Driven Recruiting: How to Predict Job Fit?

Unlock the secrets to data-driven recruiting success. Discover proven strategies for predicting job fit accurately and revolutionizing your hiring process!

You may also like

Top 50 Substitute Teacher Interview Questions and Answers

Top 50 TypeScript Interview Questions and Answers

Top 50 MongoDB Interview Questions and Answers

Unlock the next level of your recruiting workflows, download "top 50 critical thinking interview questions ".

• Why Workstream

Learn how we help you manage and pay your hourly workers.

Connect your software all under one platform

Team Operations

Team communications, payroll new.

• Restaurants
• Hospitality
• Manufacturing
• Warehousing

Featured Reads

For our customers: product roadmap sneak peek.

• Docs & Help Center

Learn how to tackle the hardest aspects of paying restaurant workers from taxes and tip reporting to labor law compliance.

Top 10 critical thinking interview questions, get free resources to help you hire, engage, and retain your hourly workforce, get the latest with workstream.

Always stay current with hiring news by subscribing to our email updates

Critical thinking interview questions are an important part of the hiring process. They help to assess a candidate's ability to think logically and make decisions. Every hiring manager should use the top 10 critical thinking interview questions to get a better understanding of the candidate's skills and abilities.

1. Describe a situation where you had to think critically to solve a problem. This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate approaches problem-solving. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's critical thinking skills and how they can be applied to the job.

2. How do you handle difficult decisions? This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate makes decisions in difficult situations. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's ability to think critically and make sound decisions.

3. What strategies do you use to stay organized? This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate manages their time and tasks. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's ability to prioritize tasks and stay organized.

4. How do you handle criticism? This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate responds to criticism. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's ability to take constructive criticism and use it to improve their performance.

5. How do you handle stress? This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate manages stress. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's ability to stay calm and focused under pressure.

6. Describe a situation where you had to think outside the box to solve a problem. This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate approaches problem-solving. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's ability to think creatively and come up with innovative solutions.

7. How do you handle ambiguity? This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate responds to uncertainty. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's ability to make decisions in the face of ambiguity.

8. How do you handle failure? This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate responds to failure. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's ability to learn from mistakes and move forward.

9. Describe a situation where you had to make a difficult decision. This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate makes decisions in difficult situations. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's ability to think critically and make sound decisions.

10. How do you handle change? This question is important because it allows the hiring manager to understand how the candidate responds to change. It also gives the hiring manager insight into the candidate's ability to adapt to new situations and environments.

Critical thinking interview questions are important because they help to assess a candidate's ability to think logically and make decisions. They also provide the hiring manager with insight into the candidate's problem-solving skills, decision-making abilities, and ability to handle stress and ambiguity.

When conducting a critical thinking interview, it is important to avoid asking questions that are too specific or too general. It is also important to avoid asking questions that are too personal or too intrusive. Additionally, it is important to avoid asking questions that are too difficult or too easy.

When conducting a critical thinking interview, it is also important to avoid making assumptions about the candidate's skills or abilities. It is also important to avoid making judgments about the candidate's answers. Additionally, it is important to avoid making any comments that could be interpreted as biased or discriminatory.

The ideal critical thinking interview should be structured and organized. It should also be tailored to the specific job and the candidate's skills and abilities. The interviewer should ask questions that are relevant to the job and that will help to assess the candidate's critical thinking skills. The interviewer should also provide the candidate with enough time to answer each question and should be open to follow-up questions.

When conducting a critical thinking interview, it is important to create a comfortable and welcoming environment. The interviewer should be friendly and approachable and should make the candidate feel at ease. The interviewer should also be patient and should allow the candidate to take their time to answer each question.

In conclusion, critical thinking interview questions are an important part of the hiring process. They help to assess a candidate's ability to think logically and make decisions. Every hiring manager should use the top 10 critical thinking interview questions to get a better understanding of the candidate's skills and abilities. Additionally, it is important to avoid asking questions that are too specific or too general, making assumptions about the candidate's skills or abilities, or making judgments about the candidate's answers. The ideal critical thinking interview should be structured and organized and should be tailored to the specific job and the candidate's skills and abilities. Finally, it is important to create a comfortable and welcoming environment for the candidate.

About Workstream

Workstream is the leading HR, Payroll, and Hiring platform for the hourly workforce. Its smart technology streamlines HR tasks so franchise and business owners can move fast, reduce labor costs, and simplify operations—all in one place.

46 of the top 50 quick-service restaurant brands—including Burger King, Jimmy John’s, Taco Bell—rely on Workstream to hire, retain, and pay their teams. Learn more at workstream.us.

Subscribe to our newsletter

More resources

Other interview questions.

Top interview questions for a Cook

Top interview questions for a Cashier

Top interview questions for a Dishwasher

Top interview questions for a Kitchen Manager

RELATED HOURLY WAGES

Hourly wages in Arizona

Hourly wages in California

Hourly wages in Florida

Hourly wages in Utah

Hourly wages in Texas

OTHER RESOURCES

Post a job in City

Job description for hourly workers

Hire restaurant workers

We’re here to help!

A Workstream hiring specialist can help you identify high impact ways to improve your applicant experience, and even help you determine what is a good hourly wage for your location and business.

17 critical thinking interview questions to find the perfect candidate

Find top critical thinkers for your open roles today.

Critical thinking is an important skill in any role, and its significance only increases the more complex responsibilities employees have.

The best way to ensure your candidates have the skills to tackle sophisticated problems is to screen applicants using a Critical Thinking skills test and create a shortlist of quantifiably competent interviewees.

The next step is to ask thought-provoking interview questions. This interview process is tricky, but to help you out, we’ve created a list of 17 critical thinking interview questions to ask candidates.

Table of contents

The importance of thought-provoking interview questions, 17 critical thinking interview questions and answers, summary of all 17 critical thinking interview questions, uncover critical thinking with talent assessments and in-depth interview questions, never miss great talent with our skills tests and critical thinking interview questions .

Research shows that the demand for critical thinking and analysis is growing at a faster rate than any other skill group, likely thanks to the increased need for critical analysis when navigating technological change.

To meet this demand, hiring managers need a robust system for assessing critical thinking skills for most positions. When we talk about critical thinking, we refer to a range of sub-skills, including:

Self-reflection

These skills are essential to many business processes , particularly for managers who must evaluate complex variables to make effective business decisions. 

For example, critical thinking skills are necessary to effectively re-evaluate processes during agile project management, which drives innovation.

The problem with critical thinking skills is that it’s difficult to identify them relying solely on resume evaluation. Anyone can write “critical thinking skills” on a resume, but it doesn’t make them critical thinkers.

That’s where talent assessments come in. Skills testing measures candidates’ critical thinking skills, ensuring shortlisted candidates meet a certain benchmark. Then, asking interview questions for critical thinking gives you a well-rounded understanding of a candidate’s aptitude for objective analysis. The questions should be thorough enough to give you insight into a candidate’s motivations, problem-solving style, and decision-making skills.

Asking interview questions about critical thinking gives you insight into a candidate’s thinking style as well as relevant sub-skills, such as: 

Decision-making

Problem-solving

Information processing

Deductive reasoning

Conflict resolution

In candidates’ answers to all these critical interview questions, look for their ability to: 

Give a clear, concise, structured answer – for example, using the STAR method , outlining the situation, task, action, and result

Illustrate their points with specific examples 

Reflect honestly on their strengths and weaknesses

Show self-awareness about areas for improvement

So, what are some critical thinking interview questions?

1. How do you go about completing a task without clear information?

Answers to this question should show how the candidate would perform in time-sensitive environments, where workers often make decisions with incomplete information. 

Based on the answers, gauge how the candidate would handle the lack of information in complex situations, including: 

How they review the information they have 

How they use creative thinking to fill in the blanks

What experiences, resources, or training they draw on to make educated guesses about missing data 

How they decide on a solution 

Whether they continually use analytical skills to re-evaluate their chosen solution as they receive more information

What the outcomes have been in past instances of doing tasks while missing information

2. What is the most difficult work-related decision you’ve had to make?

This critical thinking interview question probes candidates’ ability to make sound decisions under pressure. A good answer shows a clear thought process and measured judgment to select a course of action.

Look out for candidates who can: 

Lay out all the variables involved in the decision 

Explain why these factors were at odds with each other and what the stakes were

Reflect on how they handled the stress of the decision 

Show that they created a logical system for making the decision – and stuck to it 

Display willingness to take ownership of their decisions even in difficult circumstances, such as layoffs

3. How do you process new ideas and approaches?

Open-mindedness is central to critical thinking. Candidates shouldn’t fear abandoning traditional methodologies if a superior alternative emerges. Equally, they should exercise their judgment to evaluate whether a new method meets the bar. 

When a candidate answers this question, look out for: 

Awareness of new ideas and approaches emerging in their field – this is a sign that a candidate is proactive and engaged in their work

An established process for fact-checking or testing new approaches

Ongoing reevaluation of new methods and ideas

Adaptability and willingness to consider ideas that contradict their way of doing things 

4. How do you respond to opposing viewpoints?

Critical thinking depends on a person’s ability to weigh both sides of an argument. Even when one course of action is worse than another, candidates should be able to respond to opposing perspectives respectfully and constructively.

Candidates with strong critical thinking skills:

Show they understand opposing viewpoints

Practice active listening to ensure everyone feels heard

Identify the conflict between others’ ideas and their opinion 

Address this conflict respectfully and back up their views with hard evidence 

Where applicable, shift their viewpoint according to new information or reach a suitable compromise

5. How quickly do you make decisions?

In a fast-paced work environment, employees must act swiftly and decisively. This critical thinking interview question asks the candidate to expand on their decision-making process. Strong answers strike a balance between careful consideration and urgency, showing:

An understanding of decision-making timelines in their role or industry: quicker isn’t always better, and making snap decisions is often a sign of arrogance

An awareness of the time needed to make different types of decisions and which stakeholders are involved 

Methods for assessing how much time they have to make a decision and how they manage their tasks to stay on track

Variables they prioritize in decisions they have limited time to make

6. Have you ever anticipated a complex problem before it arose? How did you deal with it?

This critical thinking interview question separates the proactive thinkers from the passive ones, helping you spot candidates who plan and anticipate risks – an invaluable skill in any organization.

Good answers to this question show: 

A solid understanding of the key functions or outputs of their business and the resources these rely on 

Proactive evaluation of changes to this environment

Risk assessment and risk management skills , and knowing when to take action and when to hold off

7. What work-related advice would you give to former employers?

This question gauges a candidate’s propensity to voice criticism and whether they express it constructively or negatively. There’s no right or wrong answer here. Candidates simply need to thoughtfully explain suggestions for managers in their previous roles.

“Green flags” when looking at candidates’ answers to this question include: 

An awareness of the factors that went into their bosses’ decision-making 

A clear explanation of their disagreements or amendments to these policies 

Practical suggestions for improving the situation 

A “red flag” would be making personal or non-constructive remarks or failing to show understanding and respect for former employers.

8. How often do you ask coworkers for help?

Workers should know when to seek help from others while working on a project. They shouldn’t burden co-workers with work they could do themselves, nor should they be too stubborn to proceed without some outside opinion or help.

Keep an eye out for candidates who:

Understand which tasks in their role are suitable for collaboration and which require independence 

Show willingness to look for their own solution before asking others for help 

Know their limitations, particularly within time constraints – for example, when to ask for help from a colleague who can complete a task faster 

Awareness of and respect for their colleagues’ priorities 

A willingness to learn so this situation is less likely to repeat itself

9. How should friction between team members be dealt with?

Conflict resolution is a skill that’s hard to come by for hiring managers. In work environments with people with different opinions and values, it’s important to have someone who can defuse conflict situations with a proactive, patient, and impartial approach.

Look for candidates who: 

Know the difference between healthy and toxic conflict

Understand organizational or legal protocols for conflict resolution – for example, which situations should be dealt with formally 

Resolve conflicts using non-violent communication

Are familiar with processes for restabilizing the team after conflict resolution

10. What is the most innovative work-related idea you have come up with? How did it benefit the organization?

This question asks candidates to describe past experiences of thinking outside the box to deliver a new solution. Having proactive problem-solvers in your organization helps it stay ahead of the curve. 

A good answer to this critical thinking interview question shows that a candidate: 

Is on the lookout for opportunities to innovate or optimize processes

Comes up with practical ways to implement their solutions

Stands up for their ideas if they’re not met with enthusiasm initially

11. Describe a situation when you received negative feedback you didn’t understand.

If applicants have received negative feedback they didn’t understand, getting defensive should not be their first instinct. An employee who analyzes situations critically should know that the feedback could enhance the quality of their work and strive to understand it better.

Look out for candidates who show: 

A willingness to receive critical feedback 

The ability to restate what they heard and ask for clarifications on aspects that elude them

A keenness to follow up with the supervisor and ask about their progress since the feedback was given

12. Describe a time you made a serious mistake at work.

Owning up to past mistakes shows applicants’ integrity and honesty. How they describe the mistake and their subsequent actions should hint at the strength of their critical analysis ability. Ask yourself: 

Are they able to explain what they learned from the mistake? 

Can they describe how they took accountability for their errors?

Did they use the errors as learning opportunities?

Has the mistake reoccurred, or have they used this lesson to prevent it?

13. Describe a digital skill you need to improve.

Companies worldwide are experiencing massive shortages of digital skills, even among younger workers. One UK-based survey found that employers believed some of the top skills graduates lacked were:

Basic IT skills

Data ethics

Machine learning

Programming

Data communication skills

A good answer to this question should show that candidates understand the importance of mastering digital processes. 

It also shows that the candidate has the critical thinking skills needed to recognize these weaknesses in their digital know-how, particularly where they impact their job.

Ask them if they are taking courses or reading books to improve.

14. Do you have any methods for improving your problem-solving skills?

Problem-solving skills are an adjunct of critical thinking that prepares candidates for handling challenging assignments by prioritizing tasks, planning and executing strategies, and anticipating additional problems. 

To improve their problem-solving skills, candidates can: 

Share ideas with coworkers to learn new problem-solving strategies

Improve analytical skills to assess the root causes of problems

Practice creative and critical thinking

Assessing your applicants’ problem-solving skills is quick and simple with our Problem Solving and Critical Thinking tests. Use these tests for a data-driven hiring process.

Spot top problem-solvers without bias

Find out how our skills tests can help you find the best hire for your open position.

15. Have you ever received negative feedback from senior management?

Negative feedback from senior managers may seem jarring, but employees should see it as a wake-up call and an opportunity to improve performance. Your applicants should show their critical thinking aptitude by explaining:

How they accept negative comments from senior leadership 

What they do to implement the necessary changes to their work 

How they use it as a learning opportunity

Ask your candidates to provide an example of a time they received negative feedback and ask extra questions to see how the criticism improved their work.

 For instance, if a senior manager reproached an applicant for not motivating a team effectively, you may ask, “How did your motivational strategies change after that?”

16. How would you coach an employee who’s failing to meet targets?

Coaching enables underperforming team members to enhance their approach to the task and achieve their goals more efficiently. Successful coaching demands critical thinking skills on the mentor’s part to inform the best strategy. 

Consider whether your applicants have coaching experience and can provide an example of a situation when their coaching strategies helped an employee who was failing to meet targets.

Strategies they could mention include:

Scheduling one-on-one meetings to discuss company targets 

Using efficient communication to share their expectations with the employee

Evaluating the reasons why the team member is struggling 

Looking for ways to help them address challenges with training or mentorship

17. How do you ensure your team trusts your choices?

Team management requires strong critical thinking skills because managers must understand what motivates each of their team members, communicate their decisions in a way that resonates with them, and project reliable authority.

Examples of how candidates could do this include:

Being transparent in their decision-making process 

Admitting mistakes 

Communicating effectively

Using team-building activities

Holding regular team meetings

Whichever method they use, applicants should describe the outcomes of their processes to help you appraise their managerial expertise.

What are examples of critical thinking questions? Here’s our full list of critical thinking questions and answers.

In traditional hiring, the earliest you could assess critical thinking skills is during the interview. Hiring managers spend much time and effort inviting candidates to interviews and prepping the questions, only to find they aren’t suitable.

This situation doesn’t happen if you screen candidates using TestGorilla’s Critical Thinking test , which evaluates their basic critical thinking abilities with questions like this:

Using skills-based hiring during the shortlisting process lets you cut out the time you’d otherwise spend checking if candidates have critical thinking skills.

Instead, you can look more closely at how they approach problems with interview questions for strategic thinking. Then, you can evaluate whether their approach would work in your business environment.

This approach leads to better hires and a shorter time to hire. For example, the game development and publishing studio Visionaries FZ-LLC saves 15 hours per hire by only inviting candidates to interview if they score above 80% on TestGorilla’s assessment.

Don’t waste time finding skilled candidates.

Create your first multi-measure assessment for free with TestGorilla today.

Critical thinking is at the top of the list when deciding what to assess with your interview questions. In this article, we’ve broken down: 

Why critical thinking skills are so important 

A list of the best critical thinking questions for interview candidates

How skills testing can help you create even better thought-provoking questions for interviews

To learn how to get started with skills testing, sign up for a demo with one of our experts today. 

You can also look around our platform yourself by taking a product tour .

Or, if you’re ready to get started straight away, sign up for our Free forever plan now.

Related posts

7 job offer templates for entry-level, managers, internships, and more

What is a hostile work environment? Signs and solutions

Case manager job description template: Everything you need to include

You've scrolled this far

Why not try TestGorilla for free, and see what happens when you put skills first.

Latest posts

The best advice on pre-employment testing, in your inbox.

No spam. Unsubscribe at any time.

Hire the best. No bias. No stress.

Our screening tests identify the best candidates and make your hiring decisions faster, easier, and bias-free.

Free resources

This checklist covers key features you should look for when choosing a skills testing platform

This resource will help you develop an onboarding checklist for new hires.

How to assess your candidates' attention to detail.

Learn how to get human resources certified through HRCI or SHRM.

Learn how you can improve the level of talent at your company.

Learn how CapitalT reduced hiring bias with online skills assessments.

Learn how to make the resume process more efficient and more effective.

Improve your hiring strategy with these 7 critical recruitment metrics.

Learn how Sukhi decreased time spent reviewing resumes by 83%!

Hire more efficiently with these hacks that 99% of recruiters aren't using.

Make a business case for diversity and inclusion initiatives with this data.

13 critical thinking interview questions to use

If you’re looking to fill a position that requires precise and rational decision-making skills, critical thinking interview questions are an essential component in your interview process .

Many hiring managers overlook this veiled job requirement and skill because it’s not always easily assessed. Some candidates have the technical skills and experience but might not have the emotional intelligence or critical thinking skills to succeed.

That’s where interview questions to assess problem-solving skills can come in handy.

What is critical thinking?

Critical thinking is a thought process that allows a person to evaluate and assess information objectively and calculate responses and judgment. Critical thinking can be compared to rash, reactive thought processes which generate immediate and purely emotional responses.

In the workplace, people with critical thinking skills are highly valued as they usually provide rational advice, thought-out solutions, and fair assessments.

It’s tough to establish the level of a candidate’s critical thinking skills unless you specifically look for it during the interview process. Critical thinking interview questions are one of the tools available to hiring managers to gauge how a candidate will handle unpredictable situations that may arise on the job.

Tailored critical thinking interview questions

There are plenty of examples of different types of interview questions available, but your questions must relate to the position and the environment in your company. For example, if the role requires critical decisions on a technical level, the questions must be structured around the relevant skill. If the role requires critical thinking around people (customers or staff), focus on people skills.

There’s a trend to ask brainteaser questions during interviews to measure a candidate’s response, but please don’t go that route. It’s pointless! Asking something like “Jo is one of three children. Her sisters are named May and June. What’s the third child’s name?” is meaningless.

Whether the candidate answers “Jo” correctly or says “probably April” tells you nothing about their critical thinking abilities or anything else.

Apart from potentially making a candidate feel confused and uncomfortable, you could have them questioning how genuine you are.

Plan every step in the recruitment process before the interviews start. If a role needs rational decision-making, a list of critical thinking interview questions must be compiled, preferably by the hiring team rather than just the hiring manager. Collaborative thinking and inclusive staff recruitment allow for different opinions and perspectives of the same role and its requirements.

Ensure that your interview questions are challenging

These questions aren’t intended to be easy. Questions must be thought-provoking. Make the candidate think about how they would respond to and react in specific, tricky situations. You’re not necessarily looking for the right or wrong answers or solutions. Instead, you’re evaluating the candidate’s response rather than skill.

Virtually every department has positions that profoundly impact outcomes for other team members, customers, production, sales, your company brand, etc. Staff who hold these positions require well-developed critical thinking skills.

When compiling your list of interview questions, go way beyond the job skills or experience needed. Analyze what the impact of poor decision making in this role will have on existing staff, customers, your brand, and your business as a whole.

Once you’ve isolated the areas of influence connected to the role, you can start compiling your list of questions. We’re splitting the question examples into technical roles and roles that involve people skills. Your vacancy might be a combination of both. There can never be a template for critical thinking interview questions because each position and company differs, so use these as a guide to inspire you.

Critical thinking interview questions for hard skills

• What would you do if you had a looming project/production deadline, but you didn’t yet have all the information/components to deliver on time?
• If you’ve figured out a quicker or more cost-effective solution to a problem, but your manager doesn’t get what you’re saying, what would you do?
• If there’s a weak link in your team or supply chain that’s impacting productivity, how would you approach the problem?
• What would you do if a customer or manager was trying to push a project through at the expense of other projects that already have confirmed delivery dates?
• When you’re in a team of specialists, you can easily find differences of opinions on what direction projects should take. How do you find consensus?
• Have you ever had to convince a manager to try out a different solution to solve a problem?

Critical thinking interview questions for soft skills

•  An order hasn’t been delivered to a customer on time, and they’re furious. They want you to cancel the order and close their account immediately. How would you repair the damage and keep the customer?
•  Business has slowed, and you’re in a sales brainstorming session. Someone suggests lowering prices and focusing more on customer satisfaction. What’s your reaction?
•  You have an employee who’s excellent at their job, but is blunt and abrasive with colleagues and that’s causing friction in your department. How do you resolve the matter?
•  You’re in a meeting, and your manager misquotes pricing or a process that can have a significant impact on your department or a project. What do you do?
•  You notice that your manager (or a colleague) is inclined to shift blame and not accept responsibility when under pressure. How do you approach the subject?
• If you had to make a decision based on incomplete information, how would you approach this?
• How would you handle a situation where you and your teammates disagree on how to move forward on a project?

What are you looking for when asking critical thinking interview questions?

You’ll notice that the issues listed above are very broad and there’s no right or wrong answer or outcome.

• What you’re looking for is how the candidate responds. Each question is a hypothetical situation that has the potential to become a big issue if not resolved properly.
• People who have high emotional intelligence and developed critical thinking skills won’t give you any old answer. Faced with a complicated situation, their critical thinking will kick in, and they’ll most likely ask you some questions for more clarity. Don’t be surprised if you get an “mmm, I’ll have to think about that…” response initially — people with developed critical thinking process information before reacting or responding.
• People who don’t ask for more details, and don’t think before responding, likely don’t have developed analytical skills. They’re also more inclined to poor, emotional decision making.

8 benefits of critical thinkers

Critical thinkers who are capable of unbiased and fair judgment all have the following abilities:

• Developed analytical skills: They analyze situations carefully.
• Good reasoning skills: They reason in a logical and fact-based way.
• Solid emotional perception: They can separate truths from lies and point them out.
• Social experience: They conduct further research or fall back on past experiences for reference. They apply known and accepted standards and limit bias.
• Comparative analysis: They distinguish between variances and make comparisons.
• Solution-oriented thinking: They envision a solution and its potential consequences.
• Calculating actions: They quantify their conclusions and take decisive action.
• Creative thinking: They convert the situation from a negative to a positive.

This process may be gradual, developing as a situation evolves, or decisions may be made quickly depending on their skill level. Whether they have to think on their feet or address long-standing problems, people with well-developed critical-thinking skills can face a given situation and resolve it in the best way possible. They also don’t hesitate to make unpopular decisions if it’s in the best interest of the company or people involved.

Use all interview and assessment tools available

For crucial positions, you’ll need more than just a list of critical thinking interview questions to establish if a candidate is a good fit for the role. Psychometric assessments can give you more insight into a candidate’s personality.

Past employment references are also an excellent tool to establish how a candidate has handled pressures in similar situations previously. Past behavior can be a predictor of future behavior, but is not foolproof either. As people mature and environments change, so can their attitude and their aptitude in the workplace.

Tania is the Head of SEO and Content at Tellent. She's been a hiring manager for over 8 years and enjoys learning about recruitment and people management topics, in addition to solving user pain points through content.

Get the MidWeekRead

Get the exclusive tips, resources and updates to help you hire better!

Hire better, faster, together!

Bring your hiring teams together, boost your sourcing, automate your hiring, and evaluate candidates effectively.

Recruitment software built for the new way of hiring

Streamline recruitment from acquire to hire ->

Automatically pinpoint top performers fast ->

Kick-off onboarding before day one ->

Hire elite healthcare teams that elevate patient care ->

Medium to Large

Recruit, run, and grow a winning team with Elevatus

Recruit the best educators for your school

Financial Services

Secure the best finance professionals fast

Build public sector teams that you can trust

+ View all industries

HR Resources

The Ultimate 10 Critical-Thinking Interview Questions for Evaluating Genuine Problem-Solvers

June 17, 2022

Reem Al-Tamimi

Content Writer

Turn top talent to employees fast

Hire, assess, onboard and manage top talent for every job. See how Elevatus streamlines everything; from acquire to new hire.

Don't miss a thing!

Stay one step ahead. Subscribe and get the latest updates, news, and insights from Elevatus straight to your inbox.

Ever wondered why hiring a problem solver is crucial for employers? 

In the quest to build an exceptional team, recruiters possess the amazing ability to unlock minds and uncover extraordinary talents. According to a recent AACU report , 93% of employers prioritize critical thinking skills over an undergraduate degree. By carefully crafting the interview process, they embark on a captivating journey to identify candidates with the sought-after skill of critical thinking. These remarkable individuals possess the rare talent to navigate uncharted territories, solve complex puzzles, and connect ideas in profound ways.

Join us as we embark on an exciting exploration of the top 10 interview questions designed to test candidates’ critical thinking skills. Get ready to unlock minds and discover the next generation of innovative thinkers. Let’s dive in and uncover the secrets of exceptional problem solvers.

Discover the 10 Best Interview Questions for Critical Thinking Skill

The interview is a golden opportunity to evaluate a candidate’s critical thinking skills. It provides hiring managers with a window into their individual thinking processes, allowing for a tailored assessment that aligns with the role’s specific situational needs. 

By asking thought-provoking critical-thinking interview questions, recruiters can gauge candidates’ problem-solving abilities and make informed hiring decisions. 

Let’s dive into some of the best critical-thinking interview questions examples to uncover the brightest minds in the candidate pool.

Question #1: Can you share an experience where you successfully convinced your manager or team to adopt a different approach in order to resolve a problem?

This question is crucial during the interview process as it evaluates a candidate’s persuasive abilities and critical thinking skills. What you can expect from candidates is their ability to share an example where they successfully convinced their manager or team to embrace a different approach to solving a problem. 

This is one of the critical-thinking interview questions that you need to look at in its answer for candidates who demonstrate strong communication skills and logical reasoning. Plus, look for the ability to think outside the box.

Also, you need to pay attention to their ability to present compelling arguments, adapt their approach, and address any objections. A candidate’s response will provide insights into their leadership potential and their capability to drive positive outcomes through persuasive abilities. 

Question #2: Can you share an experience where you had to make a rapid decision?

With this important question from our collection of critical-thinking interview questions, recruiters have the opportunity to assess a candidate’s ability to make quick decisions. This question holds immense value as it allows candidates to demonstrate their critical thinking skills in real-time.

When candidates respond, recruiters can expect them to share a specific instance where they had to make a rapid decision. Look for candidates who can effectively communicate the context, factors considered and the reasoning behind their choice. A strong answer will showcase their quick thinking, problem-solving abilities, and the positive outcomes resulting from their swift decision-making.

Question #3: If you discovered an error in your supervisor’s report or presentation, how would you approach the situation?

This is one of the critical-thinking interview questions that are of utmost importance as it evaluates a candidate’s ability to think critically and professionally when faced with inaccuracies in their supervisor’s report or presentation. Candidates should articulate their approach to addressing such situations, highlighting attention to detail, problem-solving abilities, and effective communication.

Emphasize the importance of maintaining a positive work environment, fostering collaboration, and privately discussing the issue with the supervisor. A strong answer will showcase integrity, commitment to accuracy, and a proactive mindset in finding solutions. This thought-provoking question reveals candidates’ critical-thinking skills and their capacity to handle sensitive situations.

Question #4: Describe one of the most challenging workplace decisions you’ve had to make.

When candidates respond to this critical-thinking interview question, providing examples of challenging workplace decisions they’ve made, recruiters gain valuable insights into their problem-solving abilities. Look for candidates who can share specific instances where they faced difficult choices.

Pay attention to their ability to provide clear context, outline the factors they considered, and describe their decision-making process. A strong response will showcase their critical thinking skills, resilience, and the positive outcomes resulting from their decisions. This question allows recruiters to assess candidates’ problem-solving prowess and their potential to thrive in complex work environments. Get ready to uncover the true decision-making capabilities of candidates with this thought-provoking interview question.

Question #5: How would you react if a teammate presented you with a different or odd idea?

Diverse ideas, collaboration skills, and adaptability are key aspects evaluated in this example of critical-thinking interview questions. Candidates are asked to describe how they would respond when presented with a different or odd idea by a teammate. Look for candidates who exhibit a positive and inclusive attitude, recognizing the value of diverse perspectives.

They should demonstrate active listening, thoughtful questioning, and an open-minded approach. A strong answer will highlight their ability to foster creativity and teamwork and explore alternative solutions. Assess their communication and interpersonal skills as they navigate differing viewpoints.

Question #6: How would you handle a team member’s disagreement over how to approach a project?

Creating a harmonious and productive team environment is essential, making this one of the most important critical-thinking interview questions. Candidates are asked how they would handle a disagreement with a team member over the approach to a project. Look for candidates who demonstrate strong communication skills, active listening, and an open mindset.

They should showcase their ability to foster open discussions, find common ground, and reach a resolution while considering the project objectives. A strong answer will highlight their diplomacy, critical thinking, and problem-solving abilities in navigating conflicts. Pay attention to their capacity to promote collaboration, maintain a positive team dynamic, and achieve successful project outcomes. Assess candidates’ ability to handle conflicts constructively with this engaging interview question.

Question #7: Have you ever foreseen an issue and prepared a plan to avoid it?

Proactive problem-solving abilities are key when evaluating candidates, making this critical-thinking interview question highly valuable. Candidates are asked to share a specific example where they anticipated a potential issue and developed a plan to prevent it. Look for candidates who exhibit critical thinking skills, attention to detail, and the ability to assess risks.

They should demonstrate initiative, effective communication, and the implementation of preventive measures. A strong answer will highlight their ability to think ahead, plan strategically, and their commitment to achieving successful outcomes by avoiding potential obstacles. Get ready to uncover candidates’ proactive problem-solving skills with this one of the thought-provoking critical-thinking interview questions.

Question #8: How do you make a decision when you don’t have all the necessary information on hand?

This is one of the critical-thinking interview questions to ask candidates to assess their ability to make decisions in uncertain or incomplete information scenarios. When candidates respond, expect them to describe their approach when faced with such situations. Look for candidates who demonstrate adaptability, critical thinking, and a systematic decision-making process.

They should emphasize the importance of gathering relevant information, seeking input from others, and considering potential risks or consequences. A strong answer will highlight their ability to make informed decisions based on available data, prioritize key factors, and demonstrate confidence in their choices. Pay attention to their problem-solving skills, analytical thinking, and their ability to handle ambiguity effectively.

Question #9: How do you know when you need help from others while solving an issue or completing a task?

Self-awareness, collaboration skills, and the ability to recognize when help is needed from others are key attributes assessed by this critical-thinking interview question. Candidates are asked to describe how they identify the need for assistance in problem-solving or completing tasks. Look for candidates who demonstrate humility, effective communication, and the ability to assess their own limitations.

They should emphasize the value of seeking expertise, leveraging the strengths of others, and fostering a collaborative work environment. A strong answer will highlight their ability to balance independence with recognizing when collaboration is necessary, contributing to successful outcomes, and promoting teamwork . 

Question #10: How would you manage a situation where a teammate does not understand your approach or solution?

When candidates respond to this question, expect them to provide insights into their communication skills, adaptability, and ability to collaborate effectively. They will describe how they would manage a situation where a teammate doesn’t understand their approach or solution. Look for candidates who demonstrate patience, active listening, and the ability to explain complex ideas clearly and concisely.

They should emphasize their willingness to seek common ground, encourage open dialogue, and explore alternative methods of communication. A strong answer will showcase their ability to foster understanding, promote teamwork, and find a resolution that aligns with the team’s objectives. This is one of the critical-thinking interview questions that provide valuable insights into candidates’ problem-solving and communication abilities, making it an engaging part of the interview process.

Unleashing the Power: Assessing Critical-Thinking Skills in Interviews

In today’s fast-paced and complex work environment, the ability to think critically is highly valued. It enables employees to make informed decisions, solve problems, and drive innovation. Assessing candidates’ critical-thinking skills during interviews is essential to identify those who possess the analytical mindset and problem-solving abilities necessary for success. By understanding their mindsets, problem-solving orientation, and capacity to challenge the status quo, recruiters can select individuals who will thrive in challenging roles and contribute to the organization’s growth.

Key points to consider when assessing critical-thinking skills in interviews

Hypothetical scenarios and past examples:.

• Evaluate candidates’ problem-solving abilities using hypothetical scenarios.
• Gather examples from their prior experiences to assess their critical-thinking skills.

Quick Decision-Making:

• Look for candidates who can make solid decisions while working efficiently.
• Assess their ability to think on their feet and make rational choices under time constraints.

Innovation and Improvement:

• Identify candidates who have demonstrated a willingness to challenge existing procedures and improve processes.
• Seek individuals who actively explore ways to enhance efficiency and effectiveness.

Problem-Solving Orientation:

• Observe candidates’ enthusiasm for problem-solving.
• Look for signs of motivation and persistence when faced with challenging situations.

By incorporating these strategies into the interview process, recruiters can effectively assess critical-thinking skills and select candidates who possess the necessary mindset and abilities to excel in today’s dynamic workplace.

Last Few Words

Transforming your company into a team of critical thinkers is within reach, and it starts with making simple adjustments to your recruitment process and utilizing the right tools. By integrating interview questions to determine critical thinking skills into your recruitment solutions alongside other skill assessments, you can effectively shortlist top talent. 

Our carefully curated collection of interview questions can serve as a valuable resource to measure candidates’ critical thinking abilities, enabling you to make informed hiring choices. Embracing critical thinking throughout your organization will empower your team to tackle complex challenges, think creatively, and drive innovation.

Choose wisely, assess thoroughly, and assemble a team of exceptional critical thinkers who will shape the future of your organization. With the right interview questions, you can unlock the full potential of your candidates and pave the way for success.

Unleash the talent revolution: join 200+ leading companies to supercharge your assessment process with eva-assess today!

EVA-SSESS is an on-demand and unbiased video interviewing software that helps enterprises identify, evaluate, develop, and hire top talent in record time. Where they can assess a large pool of applicants quickly, with structured and automated video assessments that save more than 90% of their time. 200+ leading companies across the globe are relying on EVA-SSESS to build customizable assessments, get in-depth psychometric reports, detect ideal keywords, rank applicants, and create an exclusive and memorable applicant experience. Request a free demo today! 

You may also like...

Uncovering the Underlying Triggers and...

Employee turnover can be a costly conundrum for organizations, especially...

July 24, 2023

Employee Turnover vs Attrition: Decoding...

No matter the industry, the ebb and flow of employees...

July 31, 2023

Unravelling the Enigma of Employee...

Companies are like vibrant ecosystems, with employees joining and departing...

Job Crafting Unveiled: A Roadmap...

Do you ever feel like your job is holding you...

June 19, 2023

What's trending

Press Releases

Cyberani Partners with Elevatus to...

RIYADH, May 12th, 2024 – Elevatus, a pioneer...

September 16, 2024

Hiring Strategies

Revolutionary Strategies for Turbocharging Your...

As you click through yet another batch of...

Our Solutions

10 Reasons Why Elevatus is...

The world of recruitment is no longer as...

Recruitment Software

Recruitment Automation Software: Bridge the...

The second quarter of the year has already...

• Career Advice
• Job Search & Interview
• Productivity
• Public Speaking and Presentation
• Social & Interpersonal Skills
• Professional Development
• Remote Work

Eggcellent Work

12 critical thinking interview questions and scenarios with sample answers  .

As a job applicant, you can expect critical thinking interview questions and you must be prepared with logical answers. Matt Plummer, writing for the  Harvard Business Review,  cites one survey of nearly 64,000 managers who felt “critical thinking is the number one soft skill” managers feel new applicants are lacking.

Critical-thinking skills are what enable you to use reasoning to reach logical conclusions when dealing with problem-solving, conflicts, and contributing to a group effort. Interviewers typically evaluate applicants’ critical thinking skills by asking critical thinking interview questions related to the applicant’s on-the-job experience.

Applicants can also expect to react to hypothetical critical thinking scenarios with answers or to create ideas for interview presentation.

While brainteasers and  fun critical thinking interview questions  are popular with some organizations, most prefer to challenge candidates with more complex, job-related critical thinking questions.

• The Ultimate Guide To Critical Thinking
• Is Critical Thinking A Soft Skill Or Hard Skill?
• How To Improve Critical Thinking Skills At Work And Make Better Decisions
• 5 Creative and Critical Thinking Examples In Workplace
• 10 Best Books On Critical Thinking And Problem Solving

12 Common Barriers To Critical Thinking (And How To Overcome Them)

How to promote critical thinking in the workplace, here are 12 critical thinking interview questions examples with answers, or suggested approaches to crafting responses:, 1. what does the term “critical thinking” mean to you.

This is a challenging question, because there is no universal consensus on what critical thinking actually is. Critical thinking is best defined by its differentiation between emotion and logic and the ability of the critical thinker to eliminate bias through self-knowledge and avoidance of group thinking.

Sample answer to Question 1:

“I believe critical thinking is arriving at answers and solutions to difficult questions and problems in a methodical way that removes bias and uncovers every aspect of the problem.

“Critical thinking, to me, is the opposite of emotional and biased judgment. It is asking the right questions by always questioning assumptions, using reasoning and logic, and respecting the collaboration process without getting stuck in an echo-chamber of group thinking.”

2. How would you describe your decision-making process?

You can expect this question because decision making and critical thinking are directly related. The interviewer wants to have an understanding of how you make decisions, so answer this question step-by-step, showing how you make thoughtful and smart decisions based on information and data.

Sample answer to Question 2:

“My first step in making a decision is to seek and gather information relating to my decision. I want multiple perspectives and I like to anticipate a variety of possible outcomes.

“Next, I think about how my decision will impact my workgroup and the company. If necessary, and depending on the situation, I often seek a second opinion so that I didn’t miss something I may have overlooked.”

Read More: 25 Valuable Informal Interview Questions and Answers to Learn More About the Job

3. How do you process new ideas and approaches?

This question evaluates your open-mindedness, which is also central to critical thinking. Critical thinkers are not afraid of abandoning traditional methods when something better turns up. Likewise, critical thinkers exercise judgment and evaluate the veracity and reliability of new information.

Sample answer to Question 3:

“I know that new ideas drive innovation in any organization, and I always try to be receptive. If something can be improved, I know that solutions are out there and have probably been tested and evaluated. If those ideas have applicability and potential, I test them on a limited trial basis before recommending they be applied on a large scale.”

4. Describe a time you had to use critical thinking to solve a problem.

Here is where the employer wants to find out if you have actually had to use critical thinking to find a solution to some problem or challenge. This is an ideal way to bring up examples of past accomplishments you have already  documented on your résumé.

How to answer Question 4:

State the problem, and how it may have been an unexpected challenge. What were the obstacles that you overcame with critical-thinking, rather than knee-jerk responses? Describe how effective teamwork and communication made it possible to arrive at a solution.

5. How do you go about completing a task without clear information?

When short-fused deadlines emerge, you often have to make decisions lacking all the information you need. Your response will be evaluated on how you demonstrate resourcefulness and perform well in the face of those limitations.

How to answer Question 5:

Say that you prefer to make decisions after taking in all the facts, but you recognize that sometimes you need to act quickly. Describe how you look critically at all the information available and use your intuition and good judgement to fill in any information gaps.

Describe how you may have relied on similar experiences in the past with successful outcomes. This is also an opportunity to demonstrate that you are not averse to asking for help.

6. If you are faced with multiple projects but only have time to complete three, how do you decide which projects to work on?

This is a way to demonstrate how you can prioritize tasks based on their importance and urgency. Critical thinking helps you distinguish what is important from the routine by applying criteria related to time, effort, and value.

Sample answer Question 6:

“If I was faced with multiple time-sensitive tasks, rather than rushing to complete any one of them, I would list the tasks in a single document according to urgency and deadline. I would farm out the less urgent tasks to subordinates or co-workers.

“Next, from the tasks remaining, I would flag those that are both important and urgent. For those tasks, I would order them based on their importance to the organization, as well as those that could cause damage to the organization if they cannot be completed. That would also include identifying the tasks that have the highest return on investment.

“After that process of elimination, I would choose three tasks that 1) bring the most value to the business, 2) are urgent, and 3) only I can complete.

“I would deal with the tasks that didn’t make the cut by either delegating them or seeking reasonable deadline extensions.”

7. How would you present a new idea or technique to your team?

In jobs that require presenting new concepts or skills to the team, employers want to know how effectively you can share information with others.

How to answer Question 7:

Think about your learning style—visual, audible, kinesthetic, verbal—and find a way to incorporate your style with the way you present information to others. Describe, for example, how presenting information to your team includes an understanding of learning styles and knowing that people can be engaged through a variety of visual presentations.

Provide specific examples of your past successful presentations.

8. How do you respond to opposing viewpoints in your workgroup?

Critical thinkers weigh both sides of any argument. Be prepared to address how you deal with opposing perspectives respectfully and constructively, even when one view is worse than the other.

How to answer question 8:

Demonstrate that you’re always open to a variety of well-meaning perspectives in the workplace. Listening to those opposing viewpoints refines your own opinions, which has the benefit of bringing opposing views to a middle ground.

Think about a time when you and a colleague disagreed on how to proceed on a project. Describe how you listened respectfully to your colleague, presented your case, and factually demonstrated how your approach could ultimately produce the best outcome.

9. How often do you ask co-workers for help?

Self-awareness is an important element of critical thinking. You need to know when to seek help from others when you encounter difficulties or obstacles on a project.

How to answer Question 9:

Your answer should demonstrate a balance between burdening busy co-workers and being stubborn to the point of freezing progress on a project.

Mention that you normally try to avoid asking co-workers for help, since they are busy with their own work.

However, you do recognize that a fresh approach and new eyes can help you overcome obstacles. Mention, too, that you are always ready to help out when asked.

10. How should friction between team members be dealt with?

Conflict resolution is a valuable critical thinking skill. Your ability to work with people who have different values and opinions is the key element in conflict resolution skills. You need to show a proactive, patient, impartial approach to defusing volatile situations.

How to answer Question 10

Mention that workplace disagreements can promote a healthy diversity of opinion. But when those disagreements become personal, they serve no purpose and can fester into grudges and long-term, toxic workplace problems .

Think about a time when you either helped deescalate a conflict or when you observed how your supervisor was successful in handling troublesome co-workers and conflict situations.

Read More: How to Handle Conflict with a Coworker in a Professional Way

11. How would you deal with a situation where a weak link in the team is affecting the quality of performance?

This is one of those critical thinking interview questions that assesses your ability to cope with a particularly sensitive workplace problem and how you tackle it proactively. You need to demonstrate that you don’t shy away from having uncomfortable conversations in a confidential and respectful way.

This is a hypothetical question you can answer either through thoughtful preparation or based on past experience—a group project in a college class, for example.

How to answer Question 11

In a job setting, you could describe how you would cope with a team member who was disrupting the delivery of a project. Your approach would be to consult with your manager in a respectful and confidential way.

Rather than pointing fingers, to offer solutions. You need to identify the cause of the colleague’s poor performance and recommend remedial action, more training or reassignment to a project where the team member could perform better.

12. What would you do if you noticed your supervisor made a mistake?

There could be a time when you will need to correct a mistake of a higher-level employee. Your challenge is to demonstrate critical thinking skills and find a professional way to correct the mistake in an ethical, professional, and polite manner.

How to answer Question 12

Say that your approach would be to meet with the senior employee privately to tactfully and kindly explain the mistake they made. You’ll need evidence and a suggestion on how to correct the problem.

Senior employees will appreciate the private meeting and the chance to consider ways to correct their mistake.

• Critical Thinking vs Problem Solving: What’s the Difference?
• Is Critical Thinking Overrated?  Disadvantages Of Critical Thinking
• 25 In-Demand Jobs That Require Critical Thinking and Problem-Solving Skills
• 11 Principles Of Critical Thinking  
• Hiring Manager Wants Me To Meet The Team: Is It A Good Sign?

Jenny Palmer

Founder of Eggcellentwork.com. With over 20 years of experience in HR and various roles in corporate world, Jenny shares tips and advice to help professionals advance in their careers. Her blog is a go-to resource for anyone looking to improve their skills, land their dream job, or make a career change.

Further Reading...

Picky Employers: Why They Are Picky And How To Convince Them  

5 Trap Questions in Salary Negotiation Interview and How to Answer Them

How To Professionally Say “Please Keep Me In Mind For Future Opportunities”  

No comments, leave a reply cancel reply.

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Top 10 Supervisor Interview Questions And Answers

Jeff Gillis 0 Comments

By Jeff Gillis

Updated 9/1/2022.

When interviewing for a supervisory position with a company, the stakes are raised. This isn’t just an ordinary job the company is looking to fill. You’ll be in charge of other employees, so employers want to get this hire right. Since that’s the case, it shouldn’t be a surprise that supervisor interview questions are often doozies.

But what sort of interview questions for supervisors should you prepare to face? And what does a great answer look like? If you’re asking questions like that, you’ve come to the right place. Here’s a look at some common questions for a supervisor interview, along with some sample answers.

Top 10 Supervisor Interview Questions with Example Answers

Supervisor interview questions and answers are an excellent resource when you’re preparing to advance your career. They can give you outstanding insights about how to stand out, as well as ensure you’re not caught off guard by questions.

After all, there are more than 681,000 supervisors working in the United States. Plus, there are plenty of job seekers who are looking to take this first step into management. That means you will face competition, so you want to be ready.

Here’s a look at the top ten supervisor interview questions and answers, as well as some tidbits about why each question is a favorite among hiring managers.

1. What prior supervisory experience do you have?

This question is going to be one of the very first ones asked, so be ready with a great answer. When considering how you are going to respond, make eye contact and relate how your previous supervisor experience relates to what they are looking for.

Remember, the interview is not about you; it’s about them. Try and show you can fulfill their needs and solve their problems.

EXAMPLE ANSWER:

“In my last position, I had the opportunity to oversee several software development projects. My role involved coordinating the effort of cross-departmental teams, communicating change requests, monitoring the budget, and otherwise ensuring the project remained on target. With the second-most-recent project, I also had a unique opportunity. One of the developers hit an unexpected obstacle, and they were struggling to find a viable solution. While I have programming experience and likely could have handled the issue personally, I saw this as a chance to help a colleague excel. I put on my coaching hat and worked with them, asking them probing questions that were designed to get them to examine the situation in a new light. Using that approach and a supportive tone, I was able to guide them through a problem-solving process that resulted in a solution. Along with improving their technical capabilities, it ultimately boosted their critical thinking skills, allowing them to overcome a different challenge on their own during the subsequent project.”

2. What kind of salary are you looking for in relation to this supervisor position?

This is the nitty-gritty time. Just how good are you at negotiating? After all, this is the kind of question that has tripped up even the best of us, particularly if you aren’t prepared.

If you throw out a figure that’s too high, you could be talking yourself right out of a job. However, if you say a number too low, you might get hired at that rate, leaving you underpaid. Because of this, you should do some research ahead of time and find out what other supervisors get paid around your area .

By doing some salary research, you have numbers to reference during the conversation. Hopefully, when the position is posted online or in the paper, there is an expected salary that is listed with it. But keep in mind that this is just the starting point. And if there wasn’t a salary range published, you aren’t at a loss if you’ve dug into the data yourself.

However, when you approach this question, it’s best to be a bit ambiguous. After all, this is a job interview, not a formal offer. Since that’s the case, it’s wise to build in a little room, allowing you to learn more about what the company has in mind and give yourself space to adjust as you learn more about the role.

“Typically, I would prefer to leave salary discussions until I have a chance to learn more about the ins and outs of the position. However, based on what’s been presented thus far in the job posting and during this meeting, I have a general ballpark in mind. After a bit of research, it’s clear that supervisors in the area that take on similar duties typically earn $65,000 to $75,000 a year. Would you say that’s in line with the range your company is prepared to offer?”

3. Why should we hire you above all other applicants?

This question is typically challenging for candidates to answer, mainly because it’s inherently a bit uncomfortable. In the end, the hiring manager is basically asking, “What makes you so special?”

In most cases, you need to balance tooting your own horn with humility. It’s a fine line to tread, but it’s certainly one that’s walkable if you embrace the right strategy. Ideally, you want to focus on differentiators and results, quantifying the details whenever possible. That way, you can separate yourself a bit from the competition.

“At this point, I feel confident that you have a solid grasp on my applicable experience and key supervisory skills, including delegation, time management, communication, and other capabilities that all candidates who made it to the interview likely possess. However, I do believe I bring something unique to the table that can benefit your company. Currently, I volunteer with a program that focuses on supporting troubled youth. The benefit of that is I’ve learned not just about how to coach successfully but how to adapt my approach to the needs of individuals, many of whom were in distress. In total, I’ve helped 22 teens go from failing in school and considering dropping out to honor roll students engaged in extracurricular activities. It’s been a test of diligence and fortitude, but it’s also taught me a lot about the power of positive reinforcement, active listening, gentle persuasion, and recognition. I believe that experience has broadly shaped my approach to leadership, likely in a way that you won’t find in other candidates.”

4. Have you ever fired an employee? If so, how did you handle it?

Many supervisory roles involve terminating employees for a variety of reasons. Here, the hiring manager wants to learn more about how you approach this potentially challenging situation.

While this question requests an example, you can discuss how you’d theoretically approach the scenario if you’ve never fired an employee. Just make sure you start your answer by admitting you haven’t had to handle a termination previously, ensuring you’re honest about your lack of experience before diving into what you’d do.

“In my past role, I did have to fire one employee. Along with performance issues, there were well-documented, ongoing attendance problems. As a result, they were harming overall productivity since they were unreliable and underperforming. I approached the situation by calling the employee into my office for a meeting, giving them a degree of privacy. Next, I used a fact-based approach to describe the performance issues, including how attempts to remedy the issue were proving ineffective. Then, I outlined the attendance problems, as well as relevant company policy relating to that matter. Once that I was complete, I told the employee that I was sorry, but I had to let them go. I continued by stating that the termination was effective immediately and offered to walk them to their work area to allow them to collect their belongings and retrieve any company property before escorting them out of the building, per company policy. While it was challenging, remaining calm and fact-oriented helped show precisely why the termination was occurring. As a result, it went reasonably smoothly.”

5. How do you keep employees motivated?

Motivation plays a huge role in productivity, which is why the hiring manager wants to know how you’ll keep your team focused and engaged. If possible, outline an example of steps you’ve taken, either as a supervisor in a previous role or a team member stepping up to act as a leader.

“While I haven’t had the pleasure of working as a supervisor yet, I do have experience keeping team members motivated. During a project in my last position, we faced a series of challenges, which caused everyone to get disheartened, which harmed motivation. I chose to step up at that moment to try and keep the team engaged. During a project meeting, I mentioned an achievement for each individual relating to the project, expressing my admiration for their diligence and capabilities. Next, I discussed past projects that encountered struggles, focusing on how we overcame those issues to succeed. Then, I reminded everyone that we were in this together and that we’d assist one another as we worked through the challenges one by one, as well as expressed confidence that we could make this happen. Ultimately, that helped improve everyone’s mood in the moment, giving the team a renewed sense of energy. It made a difference, as we were able to refocus and work collaboratively to address challenges, allowing us to complete the project and achieve the desired result.”

6. How would you settle a conflict between two employees?

When you’re overseeing a team, you’ll play a role in conflict resolution. Since this question is posed as a hypothetical, you can simply outline your preferred approach. However, you can provide an example if you have one, so keep that in mind.

“If there was a conflict between two employees, my first step would be to gather information. I’d meet with each employee individually, using active listening skills like paraphrasing and asking clarifying questions to determine the root cause of the problem. While speaking with each employee, I’d also ask them to propose potential resolutions. That would help me understand what outcomes they were hoping to achieve, giving me more critical insights. After that, I’d mediate a conversation between the two employees, presenting what I learned during the previous discussions. Then, I’d work with them to find a resolution that would leave everyone satisfied. After the fact, I’d also monitor the situation and follow up with the employees individually. That would allow me to adjust the approach if the original plan proved ineffective, as well as monitor their mood and morale, ensuring I could act proactively until the situation was resolved.”

7. What is the largest number of people you have supervised at one time?

Overall, this question seems incredibly easy to answer. After all, the hiring manager is only requesting a single number.

However, it’s best to go beyond that when answering this question. By also describing the situation where you supervised those employees and similar pertinent details, your answer is more compelling.

“In my past role, I supervised a team of 12 employees. This included several front-line customer service workers, such as cashiers and customer service specialists, as well as a few working in support roles, such as stockers. As a result, I became highly familiar with each position, as well as how to motivate and coach a variety of personalities, which I believe will serve me well moving forward.”

8. How would your former team describe your leadership style?

With this question, the hiring manager is asking you to view your capabilities from the perspective of those you supervise. It gives them a clearer picture of the traits you exude, allowing them to determine how you’d likely come across in the role if hired.

“I believe my former team would describe my leadership style as a mix of servant and transformational leadership. I feel that one of my main purposes as a supervisor is to support and guide my team, so I’m diligent about removing roadblocks, providing coaching, and stepping in to help when they need a hand. However, I’m also growth and development-oriented. Along with examining processes to see if we can do it better, I look for opportunities to help my team acquire new skills and explore new experiences. Additionally, I consistently treat failure as an opportunity, ensuring my team can find value in the learning experience, allowing them to continue to improve and, ultimately, reach new heights.”

9. Tell me about your least favorite manager or supervisor. How did that experience shape your approach to leadership?

Many candidates view this question as a bit dastardly, mainly because it’s setting you up to potentially badmouth a past manager. However, with the right approach, you can answer it well without coming across as insulting or judgmental.

“In one of my earlier jobs, I encountered a manager whose style didn’t align with my needs. Their primary approach was most akin to micromanaging. They liked things done their way, even if it wasn’t the most efficient. Additionally, they had a tendency to get overinvolved, requesting updates far more often than necessary, and generally found reasons to speak poorly of everyone’s performance, even if the task was handled in the desired way and the quality was high. Ultimately, that experience showed me how that sort of leadership could harm morale. As a result, I work diligently to avoid the trappings of micromanaging a team. Instead, I provide a degree of autonomy, show trust by giving my employees space while getting updates at reasonable intervals to stay apprised, and embrace the power of recognition. I believe that makes me more effective, allowing me to support and guide a team without crossing into micromanaging territory.”

10. How would you begin overseeing a new team? Is there a change you’d make right away?

Here’s a question that helps the hiring manager figure out how your initial time on the job may go. If you have an example of when you started overseeing a new team based on your past work experience, you can reference it. However, it’s also fine to speak hypothetically.

“Generally, when I begin working with a new team, I avoid making any immediate changes. Instead, I spend my initial time getting to know each employee and exploring the overall team dynamic. Additionally, I focus on learning about struggles, obstacles, and roadblocks they regularly encounter that I could possibly solve, as well as what’s working well, ensuring I don’t disrupt a functional process. Only after that assessment do I consider making changes. That way, I can focus on areas that would genuinely benefit from improvement, ensuring I’m not pushing for change for the sake of change.”

30 More Common Supervisor Interview Questions

• Have you ever had to discipline an employee, and how did you handle it?
• Our supervisors are up to date on the latest technology. Do you view your tech skills as one of your strengths?
• If you were falling behind on production goals, how would you remedy the situation?
• Where do you see yourself five years from now?
• Can you see yourself staying with the company for a long time if you are hired for the supervisor position? 
• Would you live in the community around here, or do you see yourself commuting?
• As a supervisor, what is your greatest strength?
• As a supervisor, what is your greatest weakness?
• If you could improve one thing about yourself, what would it be?
• Have you ever had a good supervisor, and what made them stand out to you?
• Do you lead by example as a supervisor?
• Why would you want to leave your current job?
• What is your managing style like?
• How would you create a team atmosphere with the employees?
• How would people describe you?
• How do you think people that don’t know you would describe you?
• If needed, would you be able to work overtime?
• Are you open to suggestions from others?
• Can you keep an open mind, or are you set on making all the decisions?
• We sometimes hire people with disabilities. Would you be able to work with others effectively that are quite a bit different than you?
• Being the new hire, would you have a hard time speaking up during meetings?
• What has been your greatest accomplishment in life?
• What steps do you take to create a positive culture?
• How do you approach positive feedback? What about constructive criticism?
• Tell me about the most challenging person you’ve ever supervised. Why was it difficult, and what did you do to ensure success?
• What skill do you think all great leaders have in common?
• Can you tell me about your favorite manager or supervisor? What did you like about them? Did your experience with them shape your management style?
• In your own words, what’s the difference between being a manager and a leader?
• Tell me about a time when you were held accountable for a subordinate’s actions. What occurred, and how did you handle the situation?
• Do you have any questions for me?

This question is asked at the end of most interviews. Do not just shrug your shoulders, say not really, and then stand up to leave. The interviewer may think you are just in a hurry to get out of there and are not really interested in the supervisor position. Take advantage of this moment. Turn the tables on them with these five questions:

• What’s the biggest challenge this team currently faces that you’d like the new supervisor to solve?
• Can you describe the current team dynamic?
• What management style did the last supervisor who held this position use? Do you feel it was effective?
• Are there any upcoming changes the new hire in this role will have to lead the team through?
• How will you measure success for this position?

NOTE: For more great questions to ask in an interview, check out our article !

Putting It All Together

While answering supervisor interview questions is a bit intimidating, you can use the tips above to your advantage. Review the question and example answers. Then, start creating your own responses.

The only way to get better at interviews is to practice. Just make sure you do some research along the way, making it easier to create standout answers. After all, your foot is in the door. It is up to you to open it the rest of the way.

FREE : Job Interview Questions & Answers PDF Cheat Sheet!

Download our " Job Interview Questions & Answers PDF Cheat Sheet " that gives you word-for-word sample answers to some of the most common interview questions including:

• What Is Your Greatest Weakness?
• What Is Your Greatest Strength?
• Tell Me About Yourself
• Why Should We Hire You?

Click Here To Get The Job Interview Questions & Answers Cheat Sheet

Co-founder and CTO of TheInterviewGuys.com. Jeff is a featured contributor delivering advice on job search, job interviews and career advancement, having published more than 50 pieces of unique content on the site , with his work being featured in top publications such as INC , ZDnet , MSN and more.

Learn more about The Interview Guys on our About Us page .

About The Author

Jeff gillis.

Co-founder and CTO of TheInterviewGuys.com. Jeff is a featured contributor delivering advice on job search, job interviews and career advancement, having published more than 50 pieces of unique content on the site , with his work being featured in top publications such as INC , ZDnet , MSN and more. Learn more about The Interview Guys on our About Us page .

Copyright © 2024 · TheInterviewguys.com · All Rights Reserved

• Our Products
• Case Studies
• Interview Questions
• Jobs Articles
• Members Login

• Onsite training

3,000,000+ delegates

15,000+ clients

1,000+ locations

• KnowledgePass
• Log a ticket

01344203999 Available 24/7

Top 15+ Critical Thinking Interview Questions with Sample Answers

Critical thinking skills are in demand across various roles and industries. Interviewers often ask questions to assess your problem-solving abilities and logical thinking. To impress potential employers, use examples that highlight your analytical decision-making process. In this article, we present Critical-thinking Interview Questions you might encounter.

Exclusive 40% OFF

Training Outcomes Within Your Budget!

We ensure quality, budget-alignment, and timely delivery by our expert instructors.

Share this Resource

• Strategic Planning and Thinking Course
• Successful People Management and Team Leadership
• Leadership and Management Course
• High Performing Teams Training

Employers seek individuals who can tackle complex challenges, identify problems with finesse, and chart intelligent courses of action. This prized skill set transcends industry boundaries, making it a universal currency in the job market. Understanding Critical Thinking Interview Questions and sample answers will help you unlock the doors to your future career.  

Explore the top 15+ Critical Thinking Interview Questions and discover sample answers to ace your job interviews. Read more to improve your decision-making skills.  

Table of Contents  

1) Commonly asked Critical Thinking Interview Questions  

a) Describe an instance where you persuaded your supervisor or team to consider an alternative approach in addressing a challenge.  

b) How would you handle a situation where you noticed your supervisor made an error in a report or presentation?  

c) Describe one of the most difficult decisions you have had to make at work.  

d) How would you handle a situation where a colleague presented you with a new or unusual idea?  

e) How would you solve a disagreement among team members on how to approach a project?  

f) Have you ever anticipated potential problems and developed steps to avoid them?  

g) How do you handle making a decision when you don't have all of the information?  

h) When solving a problem or completing a task, how do you determine when you need help from others?  

i) In a live presentation to key stakeholders, you notice a mistake in your manager's report, but your manager isn't present. How do you handle this?  

j) Share an instance when you persuaded your manager to consider an alternative approach in addressing a challenge.  

2) Conclusion  

Commonly asked Critical Thinking Interview Questions

Discussed below are some of the commonly asked Critical Thinking Interview Questions.

Describe an instance where you persuaded your supervisor or team to consider an alternative approach in addressing a challenge.

“In my previous position, I frequently needed to access data from our company's database and compile it into a spreadsheet. Typically, this was done manually. However, I introduced a more efficient method by proposing the use of a specific software program and demonstrating the automated process. I outlined how this automated approach would not only save us time but also free up resources for more critical tasks.”  

How would you handle a situation where you noticed your supervisor made an error in a report or presentation?

"If I were to spot an error in my supervisor's work, I would choose to address it privately at a suitable time. During this discussion, I would point out the mistake and extend my assistance in rectifying it. I feel that maintaining the privacy of this conversation is a way to demonstrate my respect for my supervisor and their position."  

Describe one of the most difficult decisions you have had to make at work.

Interviewers pose this question to assess your ability to make decisions in tough scenarios. Your response should demonstrate how you approached a challenging choice, showcasing your problem-solving skills and how you evaluated various options to arrive at the best solution.  

How would you handle a situation where a colleague presented you with a new or unusual idea?

"I once worked with a colleague on a project, and they proposed a radically different approach from my usual method. I inquired about their approach, asking them to guide me through it and share their past success with it. The steps they recommended appeared simpler than my usual process, so we opted to adopt their method." 

How would you solve a disagreement among team members on how to approach a project?

Enhancing your critical thinking skills involves assessing conflicting perspectives and leveraging them to craft effective solutions. Analysing diverse angles of a situation can expand your viewpoint and frequently result in improved solutions. Demonstrating your capability to make decisions that benefit your team is a valuable skill to exhibit to interviewers.  

Have you ever anticipated potential problems and developed steps to avoid them?

“During my previous employment, I had the duty of arranging work shifts for the staff, and I recogni s ed that managing schedules became more intricate during the holiday season. To address this challenge, I introduced a system for requesting time off during this period, allowing me to plan schedules well in advance. Additionally, I implemented a training program to equip the staff with the skills needed to cover various roles, ensuring flexibility.”  

Unleash your creativity and analytical thinking with our Creative And Analytical Thinking Training . Join now!  

How do you handle making a decision when you don't have all of the information?

“I prefer having a wealth of inf ormation at my disposal when making decisions, although I acknowledge that this isn't always feasible . In such cases, I make an effort to gather as much relevant information as possible and use contextual clues to fill in any gaps.   

Once, when I needed guidance on a client proposal and my supervisor was unavailable, I thoroughly examined the client's creative brief for insights. The brief offered sufficient information for me to discover a potential solution to my dilemma. When I presented my findings, I felt confident in my preparation and received only minor adjustments from the client.”  

When solving a problem or completing a task, how do you determine when you need help from others?

“In the past, I've come to understand that certain situations call for assistance from others. I make this decision when I acknowledge that a task is too large for me to manage alone or when I require additional perspectives to address a particular issue effectively.   

For instance, last year, I accepted the responsibility of creating a report for an internal client with a tight deadline. While working on the report, I reali s ed that I wouldn't be able to complete it within the given timeframe , so I reached out to a colleague .”  

In a live presentation to key stakeholders, you notice a mistake in your manager's report, but your manager isn't present. How do you handle this?

“In such a situation, I would make a mental note of the mistake but not point it out immediately during the live presentation to avoid any embarrassment or disruption. Instead, I would bring it to my manager's attention after the presentation, explaining the issue and seeking guidance on the best way to rectify it.”  

Share an instance when you persuaded your manager to consider an alternative approach in addressing a challenge.

“Once, our team faced a recurring issue with a project's timeline. I proposed a more agile approach, emphasi s ing flexibility. I presented data on its success elsewhere and highlighted the potential benefits. After a discussion, my manager agreed to give it a try , leading to improved project outcomes and a more adaptive work environment.”  

While working on a project, if you find it hard to agree with your team on the next step, what steps would you take to ensure you pick the right direction and get your colleagues on board?

“In such a situation, I would first suggest holding a structured team meeting to discuss the differing opinions and perspectives. During this discussion, I'd encourage everyone to present their ideas and the reasoning behind them.   

I'd emphasise the importance of examining evidence and logic to determine the best course of action. Ultimately, the team's consensus would guide our decision, ensuring that everyone is on board with the chosen direction, promoting unity and collaboration to achieve our project's objectives .”  

Unlock your leadership excellence - Sign up for our Leadership and Management Skills Course today!  

Should you raise prices for more money or lower prices to make customers happier—what's the better way to sell?

“The best sales approach depends on the specific context and goals. If a business can justify higher prices by offering superior value, increasing prices can lead to higher revenues. On the other hand, lowering prices can improve customer satisfaction and potentially increase sales volume.  

A balanced approach might involve segmenting the market and offering different pricing strategies to cater to various customer segments. Ultimately, the key is to find the right balance between price and value to meet both revenue and customer satisfaction objectives .”  

How do you evaluate the credibility of a source of information?

“I evaluate the credibility of a source by considering several factors. First, I assess the author's qualifications and expertise in the subject matter. Then, I examine the publication source, looking for reputable and trusted outlets.   

I also check for citations and references to credible sources within the content. Additionally, I consider the publication date to ensure the information is current and relevant. Lastly, I look for any potential biases or conflicts of interest that may affect the source's reliability.”  

Share an instance where you had to change how you talk to make sure people understood what you were saying.

“In a previous job, I had to present a complex technical project to a diverse audience, including non-technical stakeholders. To ensure clarity and engagement, I adapted my communication style by simplifying technical jargon, using visual aids, and real-life analogies. This approach made the presentation accessible to everyone, fostering better understanding and buy-in from all participants, even those with limited technical background.”  

How do you prioritise tasks when faced with multiple urgent deadlines?

“When faced with a complex problem, I start by breaking it down into smaller, more manageable components. I research and gather relevant information to fully understand the issue and its context. Then, I brainstorm potential solutions and evaluate their pros and cons.  

Next, I collaborate with colleagues to gain diverse perspectives and insights. Finally, I prioriti s e the most effective solution and create a well-structured plan to address the problem systematically.”  

What steps do you take to analyse a complex problem?

Can you give an example of a time when you had to think on your feet during a crisis.

“I recall a situation during a critical project when our main supplier suddenly encountered production issues, jeopardising our timeline. In response, I quickly initiated contact with alternative suppliers, assessed their capabilities, and secured a backup source. This proactive approach ensured minimal disruption to our project and demonstrated my ability to adapt and make decisive decisions under pressure.”  

“One notable instance was when our company faced a sudden network outage during a critical client presentation. Without panicking, I swiftly coordinated with the IT team, initiated a backup plan, and reassured the client by sharing the presentation on our mobile devices. This quick thinking ensured that the meeting continued smoothly, demonstrating our commitment to resolving issues under pressure and maintaining a strong client relationship.”  

Get A Quote

WHO WILL BE FUNDING THE COURSE?

My employer

By submitting your details you agree to be contacted in order to respond to your enquiry

OUR BIGGEST SUMMER SALE!

We cannot process your enquiry without contacting you, please tick to confirm your consent to us for contacting you about your enquiry.

By submitting your details you agree to be contacted in order to respond to your enquiry.

We may not have the course you’re looking for. If you enquire or give us a call on 01344203999 and speak to our training experts, we may still be able to help with your training requirements.

Or select from our popular topics

• ITIL® Certification
• Lean Six Sigma Certification
• Scrum Certification
• ISO 9001 Certification
• Change Management Certification
• Microsoft Azure Certification
• Microsoft Excel Courses
• Explore more courses

Press esc to close

Fill out your  contact details  below and our training experts will be in touch.

Fill out your   contact details   below

Thank you for your enquiry!

One of our training experts will be in touch shortly to go over your training requirements.

Back to Course Information

Fill out your contact details below so we can get in touch with you regarding your training requirements.

* WHO WILL BE FUNDING THE COURSE?

Preferred Contact Method

No preference

Back to course information

Fill out your  training details  below

Fill out your training details below so we have a better idea of what your training requirements are.

HOW MANY DELEGATES NEED TRAINING?

HOW DO YOU WANT THE COURSE DELIVERED?

Online Instructor-led

Online Self-paced

WHEN WOULD YOU LIKE TO TAKE THIS COURSE?

Next 2 - 4 months

WHAT IS YOUR REASON FOR ENQUIRING?

Looking for some information

Looking for a discount

I want to book but have questions

One of our training experts will be in touch shortly to go overy your training requirements.

Your privacy & cookies!

Like many websites we use cookies. We care about your data and experience, so to give you the best possible experience using our site, we store a very limited amount of your data. Continuing to use this site or clicking “Accept & close” means that you agree to our use of cookies. Learn more about our privacy policy and cookie policy cookie policy .

We use cookies that are essential for our site to work. Please visit our cookie policy for more information. To accept all cookies click 'Accept & close'.

Protect your data

This site uses cookies and related technologies for site operation, and analytics as described in our Privacy Policy . You may choose to consent to our use of these technologies, reject non-essential technologies, or further manage your preferences.

• 27 Supervisor Interview...

27 Supervisor Interview Questions (and Great Answers)

15 min read · Updated on October 23, 2023

From employee to supervisor – a major career milestone

Before you can take charge in a new supervisor role, you have to get through the interview - and the best way to prepare for your upcoming supervisor interview is to practice answering these 27 supervisor interview questions. We've prepared some great, job-winning answers that you can use as inspiration and tweak with your own career experience. 

The role of a supervisor

As you can expect, with such a major career transition comes a whole host of new responsibilities. As a supervisor, you'll play a pivotal role in making sure your team works the way they're supposed to and that company goals are met. You may find yourself wearing a lot of hats, including planner, motivator, communicator , and problem solver. This is especially true considering that you're the bridge that closes the gap between upper management and staff. 

Get ready for your interview

Before you can walk into the interview room, you have to prepare yourself. The interviewer will be on the lookout for key information that proves you have the knowledge and experience to succeed, but they'll also be watching for your ability to present yourself confidently and professionally. Here are a few things you need to do in advance of your supervisor interview:

Research the company to get to know about its culture and values

Reflect on your strengths and weaknesses

Get your opening statement ready

Practice your responses to boost your confidence

Develop some strategies, like taking deep breaths and positive affirmations, to handle the stress and calm your nerves

Participate in some mock interviews to get some feedback on your presentation

Check your body language – eye contact, firm handshake, and projecting confidence

27 Supervisor Interview Questions and Answers

Now that we've covered what to do before you step inside the interview room, it's time to dive into some sample interview questions for a supervisor role. 

Behavioral questions

Behavioral interview questions are the ones where the interviewer wants you to “tell me about a time when….” These are the open-ended questions that you can to use the STAR method to answer.

1. Describe a situation where you had to resolve a conflict among team members

“At ABC Company, I worked in a team of 10 people and three of them were constantly having conflicts. I sat down with them individually to find out what was going on and then had a group meeting to discuss company values and policies. In that group meeting, we hashed out some compromises that put the problems the three were having to bed. It was great because getting them to work together again without all the hostility improved the morale of the entire team.”

2. How do you handle underperforming employees, and can you provide an example?

“Of course, the first step is to find out why they are underperforming. It does no good to reprimand and threaten someone for underperforming if the root of the problem isn't fixed. While I'm not a Psychologist, I would try to help the employee to find a centered, more balanced approach to doing the work. Outside of that, I've found that setting clear goals and even providing additional training have helped a lot.”

3. Share an experience when you successfully implemented a new process or procedure

“When I worked at XYZ Corp, there were a lot of manual processes – from taking customer orders to purchasing. It was a pen-and-paper type of environment. I did some research and found an ERP system that allowed us to automate a lot of those processes. Team morale sky-rocketed, because jobs became easier, and we saved about $10K a month because purchasing was more accurate.”

4. Give an example of how you've motivated your team to achieve a specific goal

“Once we had that ERP system in place at XYZ Corp, I wanted to help the team get used to using it. So, I implemented a little friendly competition. Basically, whoever used the system the most, and did so with the fewest errors, would win a half day off work. This forced everyone to take the time to learn the system - some even did research about it on their own time.” 

5. Discuss a time when you had to make a tough decision under pressure

“Early in my career, there was an equipment failure that almost stopped production in its tracks. Of course, that would've meant major revenue loss. I got the team together to discuss the resources everyone had, based on their role in production, so I could figure out how to reallocate very limited funds to get the problem fixed without sacrificing safety or further damage to the machinery. The team and I came up with some temporary fixes while we waited for the repairs to be completed, which meant we were able to keep up with customer demand and minimize losses. The quick decisions I made got everything back up and running three days in advance of the deadline set by leadership.”

Leadership and management questions

Of course, you can expect that there will be some role-specific supervisor interview questions where the hiring manager wants to make sure that you know what will be required of you.

6. What is your leadership style, and how does it benefit your team?

“I've learned that the transformational leadership style serves me well. In the past, I've found that leading by example and building open relationships with staff has inspired them to strive for excellence. They want to know that they're being asked to do something that leadership does, too. It's also been a great way to inspire innovation, which leads to employees feeling a sense of ownership in the work they perform. This has, of course, had a profound impact on productivity and team morale.”

7. How do you handle a demanding boss or difficult situations with higher management?

“Through open communication, respect, and delicacy. A lot of it comes down to having well-researched and articulated solutions to issues that are causing the boss to be demanding. I analyze the situation and provide data and evidence to support any recommendations I make. I also take the time to highlight my team's achievements and contributions, so that higher management can feel assured that they're making the right decisions to remedy whatever is causing them to be demanding.”

8. What is the biggest responsibility of a supervisor regarding safety?

“It all comes down to the culture I create with my staff, so that they understand how important things like safety training and protocols are to maintaining safety. While I maintain the final decision on what constitutes a safe environment, I allow them to have some input on what they can do to make things safer. This gives them ownership and they're more likely to follow procedures.”

9. Differentiate between the roles of a supervisor and a manager

“As a supervisor, I understand that I'll have the duty of overseeing daily activities. I know I have to offer guidance and support to ensure that what needs to be done gets done. On the other hand, the managers are the ones who make the long-term plans and upper-level decisions that affect the broader aspects of achieving company goals.”

10. Provide an example of how you've fostered a culture of continuous improvement in the past and how productivity or efficiency was affected

“When I worked at XYZ Inc., our project team was running into a lot of bottlenecks in the project delivery process. So, I held a team meeting and encouraged them to challenge the status quo by brainstorming solutions. While some tried to adopt the this-is-the-way-we've-always-done-it mentality, others came up with ideas to streamline processes. We ended up adopting new software that automated some of the steps. The team members who helped to brainstorm the idea had an infectious attitude toward embracing the change, that brought the status quo folks over to the new way of doing things. In the end, we increased productivity by around 40%.”

Self-development questions

Continuous development is a big deal in today's work world. These questions will tell the interviewer if you're committed to the role and where you stand on keeping up with the times, going with the flow, and adapting to change.

11. How do you continuously improve your supervisory skills?

“I firmly believe in learning something new every day. It's the only way to keep up with the rapid changes occurring in this industry. I attend workshops and seminars and subscribe to industry newsletters. I keep in touch with people in my network, too. That's ultimately been my best source of new information.” 

12. What qualities do you believe an ideal supervisor should possess?

“The best supervisor leads by example. I don't feel it's right to ask someone else to do something I'm not willing to do myself. On top of that, fairness and empathy are also critical to building strong team morale. When the people who report to you feel like you're on their side, they're willing to work harder and are better at adapting to any changes that come down the pipeline.”

13. What makes you a good fit for the supervisor position?

“I have a history of motivating and guiding teams. In my previous roles, I received numerous accolades for the positive work environments I built. Those environments fostered a culture of innovation through strategic planning and open communication that facilitated future-facing problem-solving. I can certainly repeat that here.”

14. How do you handle stress, and what strategies do you use to stay calm under pressure?

“Mostly through deep breathing exercises. I know that most stress comes from within, so I take a moment to center myself before tackling major projects or problems. Once I find my zen, I approach situations with strategy – find out what's going on, brainstorm ways to fix the problem, and communicate the steps to my team. I've found that my ability to practice mindfulness has helped my team members to reduce their stress, too.”

15. What's your greatest weakness, and how do you manage it to be an effective supervisor?

“I have a tendency to be overly critical of myself. It's part of the reason that I've developed calming strategies and analytical tactics that help me to get through issues that come up. When I first realized I was too critical of myself, I sought out constructive feedback from peers and learned to set realistic expectations. This way, I shifted my focus to self-improvement and away from perceived shortcomings .”

16. Discuss your strengths as a supervisor

“I am really good at motivating my team. In fact, I've been able to guide lackadaisical staff members, who were only at work to collect a paycheck, to a place where they had a stronger sense of ownership in their role. This strength comes into play through my ability to set clearly defined goals and a vision for higher standards. I also encourage open communication and transparency that promotes a positive work culture .”

17. How has your supervision style changed over time?

“When I first started as a supervisor, I focused a lot on managing tasks. I learned that the best way to do that was to have a properly motivated team. Now, I place greater emphasis on open communication, feedback, and inclusion. This has allowed my teams to blossom into cohesive groups of people who take pride in their work and achieve objectives through collaboration.”

Personal questions

You can't do a job well unless you're passionate about it. Personal supervisor interview questions will take you on a journey through what makes you want the role. 

18. Why do you aspire to be a supervisor and what drives your interest in this role?

“I believe that a good supervisor is also a mentor and I am genuinely passionate about making a positive impact on the members of my team and the company as a whole. I love watching team members grow in their roles and, when I get to be a part of that by guiding them and inspiring them to be the best versions of themselves, I get a feeling of immense satisfaction.”

19. What are the three essential qualities of a supervisor and how do you exemplify them?

“It's simple, really. A good supervisor needs to know how to communicate effectively, they should be adaptable, and they should be able to motivate a team. The transformational leadership style that I've adopted during my career allows me to encourage innovation and provide opportunities for growth, which leads to team members feeling valued. That in and of itself increases productivity.” 

20. How do you make a strong impression as a supervisor?

“I can give you a one-word answer for this question – enthusiasm. I've found that enthusiasm is highly contagious. So, when I meet new team members, I make sure that they get a sense that I'm passionate about being their supervisor and welcome the opportunity to take them under my wing to help them grow professionally and personally.”

21. What are your salary requirements?

“While compensation is important, I'm more focused on aligning my skills with the requirements of the role. With that said, the research I've performed indicates that people with my skills and achievements earn $X per year. Online reviews indicated that your company offers a range of $Y-$Z for this position, is that right?”

Handling challenging scenarios

Can you handle stress ? Of course you can! Here are some pretty tough supervisor interview questions that you'll need to be ready to answer to prove it to the hiring manager.

22. What is your strategy for resolving issues with employees who resist change?

“By understanding that change can actually be scary for some people. The best course of action is to find out what's making the person resist the change. This involves open and empathetic communication to understand their concerns. After that, I give data-backed reasons for the change and talk about the benefits. If they need extra training to support their transition, then I make that available to them, too.”

23. How do you ensure effective communication within your team?

“When I worked at ABC Company, I started using Slack for digital collaboration. It was a great tool that allowed team members to engage in open communication – whether they were in the office or not – and gave me the opportunity to keep up with the status of ongoing projects. It ended up improving efficiency, because there were fewer emails to dig through and people could get answers to questions more quickly.”

24. What is your approach to performance evaluations and feedback?

“I believe feedback should be frequent and specific. Evaluations that are only done once per year are often seen as a chore for supervisors but, when you engage in regular feedback, problems are addressed quicker and staff members learn what they're doing right as projects progress. More frequent feedback also encourages accountability. When team members know that reviews are coming more often than annually, they tend to be more productive.”

25. How do you motivate underperforming team members?

“The most impactful method I've used to increase motivation is friendly competitions. I've also used brag boards that allow team members to gain recognition for work well done. No matter which method I use, though, I make sure that it's constructive because the overall goal is to improve confidence. When their confidence increases, their ability to perform goes up, too.”

26. How do you onboard new staff members?

“I have a very structured approach to welcoming new staff members to my team. It starts with introductions and an overview of expectations. I show how those expectations are aligned with company values and goals and make sure they have the tools they need to excel in their role. When I was at XYZ Inc., I created a mentorship program. It was highly successful, because it helped team members get to know each other and it shortened the learning curve for new staff. Plus, they felt supported and were ready to contribute from day one.”

27. Have you ever had to fire an employee?

“Yes, I've had to make the tough decision to let a staff member go. It wasn't an easy task, but I've learned that it's sometimes necessary, especially as it relates to the well-being of the team and the organization. I made sure to maintain a high level of empathy and respect, while following the company's established procedures. I also provided clear reasons for the termination and offered support to the team during the transition. At the end of the day, I was able to maintain a positive work environment and ensured that the team understood the importance of accountability and performance.”

Passionate about leadership

When you're passionate about being a good supervisor, your answers to supervisor questions will come easily. Especially if you remember that the focus should be on building relationships with team members, meeting company expectations and communicating effectively. 

Do you know how to articulate your leadership skills to answer supervisor interview questions? TopInterview can help you out and even run some mock interviews with you. 

Recommended reading:

How to Interview for a Management Position Without Experience

How to Prepare for a Promotion Interview

13 Great Interview Questions to Ask a Hiring Manager

Related Articles:

How to Prepare for a Software Engineering Job Interview

27 Financial Analyst Interview Questions (with Great Answers)

7 Common Interview Questions for an Executive Director and How to Answer Them

Need a prep talk?

Learn how to crush your interview with confidence.

Share this article:

Questions? We can help.

Our team is standing by, happy to help answer any questions or address any concerns you may have. Just send us your info and we’ll be right in touch. Or, contact us directly:

1-800-803-6018

[email protected]

Thank you! We will be in touch shortly.